Do you guys belive in a soul why or why not

[hebbewem]

Title i don’t

 

[Deleted member 14693]

Nein

 

[Deleted member 17872]

Yes

 

[hebbewem]

Nein

Yes

Why

 

[Deleted member 14693]

Why

Gibt keine Beweise

 

[hebbewem]

Gibt keine Beweise

What do you mean

 

[MoggerChad]

No. Everything you experience if just your senses (eyesight, hearing, etc.)

When you die they stop functioning, hence you don't experience anything.

Death is like an eternal full anesthesia for surgery.

 

[Magnum Opus]

Gibt keine Beweise

The thing is there aren't debunks either, it's just a question individuals can answer for themselves

 

[Deleted member 14693]

What do you mean

theres no evidence

 

[Deleted member 1140]

white people have souls

 

[hebbewem]

white people have souls

Based

 

[hebbewem]

Bad thread i don't know enough about souls

 

[MoggerChad]

The whole afterlife shit etc. is dogshit. We're all just animals and it's all primal. It even explains why we're rotting on this forum - simple natural selection, just like in the animal world.

 

[Deleted member 22099]

I'm not big into science or anything but the concept of God, the afterlife, souls etc. all sounds like BS cope to me.

 

[Deleted member 17872]

Why

Almost every culture has some conception of a soul apart from body. I have always felt my self to be distinct from my body.

 

[hebbewem]

Almost every culture has some conception of a soul apart from body. I have always felt my self to be distinct from my body.

I mean can it just mean the brain . A hard enough smash to the brain will change yoy

 

[Deleted member 17872]

I mean can it just mean the brain . A hard enough smash to the brain will change yoy

Maybe maybe not. Do you think people with brain damage are persons or not?

 

[hebbewem]

Maybe maybe not. Do you think people with brain damage are persons or not?

In full coma no. But the person clearly change with brain damage

 

[Deleted member 17872]

In full coma no.

So they are not alive and killing them is not murder?

 

[hebbewem]

So they are not alive and killing them is not murder?

Yeah it isn't we pull the plug on people like that all the time

 

[loksr]

Not worth pondering, unanswerable question
It’s one of those things you’ll only find out when the time comes
Either everything amounts to us being murder monkeys and nothing more, or some sort of cloud daddy has a mission for us

I’d say given the vastness of the universe and it only getting more and more complex the more we learn, it’d be stupid to write off pretty much anything, at least completely. (Not to mention that realistically the foundation of what the universe is could be a lie and we don’t know. If there’s a “we” at all and not just an “I.”)

 

[Deleted member 17872]

Yeah it isn't we pull the plug on people like that all the time

That has to do with economic consideration and the logistics.

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/some-people-who-appear-to-be-in-a-coma-may-actually-be-conscious/&ved=2ahUKEwi1xd7LnIj8AhVW2TgGHcQNAJc4FBAWegQIAhAB&usg=AOvVaw3EffyLiGTT5MuKPkOCib1j

 

[Deleted member 21735]

yeah, sometimes i feel like i control my body from outside

 

[hebbewem]

That has to do with economic consideration and the logistics.

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/some-people-who-appear-to-be-in-a-coma-may-actually-be-conscious/&ved=2ahUKEwi1xd7LnIj8AhVW2TgGHcQNAJc4FBAWegQIAhAB&usg=AOvVaw3EffyLiGTT5MuKPkOCib1j

Oh i was wrong i though coma people didn't really have any brain activity

 

[hebbewem]

yeah, sometimes i feel like i control my body from outside

To mucy gta 5

 

[Deleted member 17872]

Oh i was wrong i though coma people didn't really have any brain activity

You are almost always wrong.

 

[hebbewem]

You are almost regularly wrong.

Nope i am not they are person but probably diffrent person if they are completely different assuming brain activity otherwise they aren't people

 

[Deleted member 23974]

Consciousness is eternal

 

[hebbewem]

Consciousness is eternal

Copy the test and put it on lookmax because i can't read it

 

[RAITEIII]

I have had paranormal experiences so I am inclined to believe theres more than our regular bodies. I believe in our spirit, rather than soul per se.

 

[Magnum Opus]

I'm not big into science or anything but the concept of God, the afterlife, souls etc. all sounds like BS cope to me.

Science doesn't contradict belief, coexisting is possible

 

[Deleted member 23974]

Copy the test and put it on lookmax because i can't read it

just download the image

 

[Deleted member 22099]

Science doesn't contradict belief, coexisting is possible

I know. Religion just seems stupid to me

 

[hebbewem]

just download the image

I wont

 

[MoggerChad]

Soul, afterlife, religion is cope.

It's over after death. You don't have a brain anymore at that point and can't experience anything.

 

[MoggerChad]

Remember what it felt like before you were born? That's what being dead feels like.

 

[Deleted member 23974]

Soul, afterlife, religion is cope.

It's over after death. You don't have a brain anymore at that point and can't experience anything.

Assuming that consciousness is physical, death does not indicate the cessation of consciousness, rather a transformation, given infinite time.

 

[Deleted member 20652]

Yeah im muslim.

//Thomas DOM

 

[MoggerChad]

Assuming that consciousness is physical, death does not indicate the cessation of consciousness, rather a transformation, given infinite time.

BRUH

you're unconscious even when you're knocked out by a punch. Or under anesthesia. Let alone when you die.

Just jfl at this.

 

[Deleted member 23974]

BRUH

you're unconscious even when you're knocked out by a punch. Or under anesthesia. Let alone when you die.

Just jfl at this.

You are presuming that the 'self' has a uniform identity over time when consciousness is a phenomenon involving an innumerable amount of physical processes.

 

[hebbewem]

Yeah im muslim.

//Thomas DOM

Low iq

 

[hebbewem]

Assuming that consciousness is physical, death does not indicate the cessation of consciousness, rather a transformation, given infinite time.

Explain it yourself

 

[MoggerChad]

You are presuming that the 'self' has a uniform identity over time when consciousness is a phenomenon involving an innumerable amount of physical processes.

Cope

 

[ropemax]

a fool says there is no soul
But the wise man does not rush to correct him

 

[Deleted member 23974]

Cope

Explain it yourself

I am not arguing for the existence of a soul, rather the erroneous notion that death results in the end of consciousness. If consciousness is physical in the materialist view, the self, therefore, does not hold a persistent identity over time but is rather an expression of physical consciousness. Explaining the image I posted, if time is infinite, consciousness is therefore infinite as well. Death is finite, as matter can't be destroyed, only transformed; consciousness continues also, but expressed in a different form.

 

[hebbewem]

Maybe i get its like coal it can be a t Rex then to tree then human. Or energy first to heat energy then light energy.. that don't mean conciussness will stay the same because it have been transformed to something else

 

[Deleted member 3828]

white people have souls

every single race does and their souls are different

some people don't have souls
they could be clones or they sold it

 

[Deleted member 1140]

every single race does and their souls are different

some people don't have souls
they could be clones or they sold it

gingers and asians 100% dont have souls

 

[Deleted member 23974]

Maybe i get its like coal it can be a t Rex then to tree then human. Or energy first to heat energy then light energy.. that don't mean conciussness will stay the same because it have been transformed to something else

You are on the right track here, but you make the mistake of assuming that there are multiple individual 'consciousnesses' (idea of self) when in a physicalist universe, there are no individual distinctions, rather pure Consciousness as an ontological reality.

 

[Deleted member 3828]

gingers and asians 100% dont have souls

a fool says there is no soul
But the wise man does not rush to correct him

monk logic
>meditate
>fuck everybody else

then they reincarnate to farm dharma