_MVP_
Investment Analysis
- Joined
- Jul 15, 2022
- Posts
- 44,445
- Reputation
- 44,777
is everything possible? if not, list some things that are impossible
Not everything is possible, especially when it comes to the physical laws that govern our universe. While the scope of "possibility" in the abstract (like in mathematics or philosophy) is vast and open to interpretation, the physical reality we experience does have constraints—things that are impossible according to our current understanding of the laws of nature. Here are some things that are generally considered impossible based on these laws:
That said, it's important to remember that science is always evolving. What we consider "impossible" today may be reconsidered in the future as our understanding deepens, or as new technologies and discoveries change the landscape of possibility. For now, though, these things are impossible within the framework of our current scientific knowledge.
4o mini
ChatGPT:
Not everything is possible, especially when it comes to the physical laws that govern our universe. While the scope of "possibility" in the abstract (like in mathematics or philosophy) is vast and open to interpretation, the physical reality we experience does have constraints—things that are impossible according to our current understanding of the laws of nature. Here are some things that are generally considered impossible based on these laws:
1. Faster-Than-Light Travel
- Why it's impossible: According to Einstein's theory of relativity, nothing can travel faster than the speed of light in a vacuum. As an object approaches the speed of light, its mass increases, and it requires increasingly more energy to continue accelerating. To reach the speed of light would require infinite energy, which is physically impossible.
2. Perpetual Motion Machines (First and Second Laws of Thermodynamics)
- Why it's impossible: A perpetual motion machine would operate indefinitely without an input of energy, violating the First Law of Thermodynamics (conservation of energy). It would also violate the Second Law of Thermodynamics, which states that entropy (disorder) in a closed system tends to increase over time. All real machines lose energy to friction, heat, or other inefficiencies, and thus cannot run forever without energy input.
3. Time Travel to the Past
- Why it's impossible: While time dilation (the slowing of time at high velocities) is possible according to relativity, time travel to the past creates paradoxes like the "grandfather paradox" (where you could potentially prevent your own existence by altering past events). The laws of physics do not currently allow for time travel to the past in a way that would be consistent with causality.
4. Traveling Backwards in Time (Causality Violation)
- Why it's impossible: If you could travel backwards in time, you could potentially affect events in such a way that they create contradictions or loops. This violates the principle of causality—the idea that cause precedes effect. The laws of physics, particularly the behavior of entropy, suggest that time has a definite forward direction, and reversing that direction could cause paradoxes that would destroy the consistency of reality.
5. Creating a Perfect Vacuum (Absolute Zero)
- Why it's impossible: Absolute zero (0 Kelvin, or -273.15°C) is the theoretical temperature at which all molecular motion stops. However, due to the Third Law of Thermodynamics, it is impossible to reach absolute zero. In practice, there will always be some residual energy present in any system, and this prevents the complete cessation of motion.
6. Negative Mass or Energy
- Why it's impossible: Negative mass is a hypothetical concept that would have properties opposite to those of normal mass—if you push it, it would move in the opposite direction. While some speculative theories in physics, like certain solutions to Einstein's equations in general relativity, allow for "exotic matter" with negative energy, there’s no evidence that negative mass exists in reality. The consequences of negative mass would also create a breakdown of basic physical principles like energy conservation.
7. Violating the Conservation of Energy
- Why it's impossible: The conservation of energy is one of the most fundamental laws of physics. Energy can neither be created nor destroyed, only converted from one form to another. While we can harness and transform energy in various ways (like turning kinetic energy into electrical energy), there's no known process in the universe that can create or destroy total energy out of nothing.
8. Living Forever (Biological Immortality)
- Why it's impossible: While biological organisms can live for long periods, all living things eventually age and die due to the limits of biological processes, such as DNA degradation, cellular wear and tear, and the finite capacity for repair and regeneration. Biological immortality would require halting or reversing the aging process, which is not currently possible according to our understanding of biology and genetics.
9. Creating or Destroying Information (Information Paradox)
- Why it's impossible: Information is a fundamental aspect of the universe—whether in the form of the positions of particles, genetic codes, or the state of a quantum system. The no-cloning theorem in quantum mechanics suggests that it is impossible to create an exact copy of an arbitrary unknown quantum state. Similarly, the Black Hole Information Paradox suggests that information lost in black holes cannot be fully destroyed. This implies that certain forms of information conservation are fundamental.
10. Breaking the Speed of Light Barrier for Information (No Superluminal Communication)
- Why it's impossible: Quantum entanglement allows particles to be correlated across vast distances instantly, but this does not allow for faster-than-light communication, since the results of measurements on entangled particles are random and can't be controlled to send information. According to relativity, faster-than-light communication would violate causality, allowing for paradoxes and violations of the principle that information cannot travel faster than light.
11. Exceeding the Universe’s Maximum Entropy (Heat Death)
- Why it's impossible: The universe tends toward a state of maximum entropy, known as heat death, where everything will eventually become evenly distributed, and no thermodynamic processes (such as the generation of work) can occur. Once this state is reached, no usable energy will be left to perform work, and life as we know it would cease to exist. We can't "escape" this eventuality because the laws of thermodynamics dictate that entropy always increases over time.
12. Creating a "True" Copy of Yourself (Soul or Consciousness Transfer)
- Why it's impossible: Even if we could replicate every physical detail of your brain and body, it’s unclear whether that would recreate your consciousness—the subjective experience of being you. Personal identity and consciousness may be more than just the information encoded in your brain. The idea of transferring or copying consciousness into another body or machine is still speculative and faces enormous philosophical and scientific challenges. There is no current way to guarantee that a copy of your physical body would actually be you in any meaningful sense.
Why are some things impossible?
The impossibilities mentioned above are often rooted in the fundamental laws of physics, such as:- Relativity (e.g., the speed of light limit),
- Quantum mechanics (e.g., no cloning theorem, uncertainty principle),
- Thermodynamics (e.g., conservation of energy, entropy),
- Causality (the relationship between cause and effect).
That said, it's important to remember that science is always evolving. What we consider "impossible" today may be reconsidered in the future as our understanding deepens, or as new technologies and discoveries change the landscape of possibility. For now, though, these things are impossible within the framework of our current scientific knowledge.
4o mini
