Shoulder to waist ratio widht vs shoulder to waist ratio circumference? Which one is the legit measurement?

[weallburninhell]

So people saying that 2 shoulder to waist ratio is ideal, but people measure it in different ways, my question is what is the most legit measurement for shoulder to waist ratio to be attractive af,
Alpha destiny say circumference is much important than the width of the shoulder and waist, but people who analyze shoulder to waist ratio in pic is by widht

 

[Deleted member 1751]

I'd say facial width to shoulder width is legit

 

[Deleted member 3990]

ratios for the aesthetics

raw width for mogging


I would choose a 24 inch bideltoid over muh shoulder:waist ratio

 

[Deleted member 3593]

Something about the shoulder width makes it very hard to gauge whether someone is broad or not. Ie good bideltoid but mediocre biacromial.

It seems if you want that true broad look that catches eyes you need very good biacromial, just super long clavicles.