the illogic of of time determinism

Youㅤ

Youㅤ

Knowledge Knight, Fact Fight, High IQ Insight
Joined
Oct 16, 2023
Posts
11,033
Reputation
14,022
If you believe that the Present can be determined from the Past, but that you can control the Present, then that requires that u can control the Past

so either u believe u have no freewill or ur retarded

if u believe u have no freewill then idc what u say as u have no freewill arguing about freewill which is literally pointless nonsense
 
  • +1
  • Hmm...
Reactions: Wexilarious, The Homelander, Jatt and 1 other person
Time is a flat circle, we'll do this again
 
  • Hmm...
Reactions: Youㅤ
@noodlelover
 
  • +1
Reactions: The Homelander
what do u mean?
From our perspective we perceive time linearly, forward. But when we imagine it from another dimension it's actually a circle. Given that time is infinite, the probability of the same thing happening over and over again is 100%. Which means that we already had this conversation many times
 
Last edited:
  • Hmm...
Reactions: Youㅤ
From our perspective we perceive time linearly, forward. But when we imagine it from another dimension it's actually a circle. Given that time is infinite, the probability of the same thing happening over and over again is 100%. Which means we already had this conversation many times
time being infinite would make every possibility occur. but are u sure that the present occurring again in the exact same way is actually a possibility?
 
  • +1
Reactions: The Homelander
time being infinite would make every possibility occur. but are u sure that the present occurring again in the exact same way is actually a possibility?
actually i question my first statement there. can a possibility become an impossibility? something may be possible in this moment but not the next
 
  • +1
Reactions: The Homelander
time being infinite would make every possibility occur. but are u sure that the present occurring again in the exact same way is actually a possibility?
If time is infinite then that means that our reality, our universe, and this earth has formed an unfathomable amount of times in the exact same way and you and I have been born into the same life and made the same choices over and over and over again. There is no choice. It's all an illusion. Our lives are all subject to the flip of the coin, the roll of the die
 
From our perspective we perceive time linearly, forward. But when we imagine it from another dimension it's actually a circle. Given that time is infinite, the probability of the same thing happening over and over again is 100%. Which means that we already had this conversation many times
id say i agree with u

but i have to think about it

i believe the past can be revisited but at that point it will be altered
 
You are always in the present, which you have a modicum of control over, but past events shape your present experience
 
ts hurts my brain bud
 
  • +1
Reactions: Youㅤ
If time is infinite then that means that our reality, our universe, and this earth has formed an unfathomable amount of times in the exact same way and you and I have been born into the same life and made the same choices over and over and over again. There is no choice. It's all an illusion. Our lives are all subject to the flip of the coin, the roll of the die
"there is no choice" is a retarded notion. common sense tells one there is choice. no model can subtract that, it should build on the foundation of the intuitively known existence of choice.

the amount of implications of "there is no choice" is absurd. generally its good to look at how people behave to assess their beliefs. u nor anyone else i have observed who says "there is no choice" behaves as if they believe they have no choice.

also are u implying that randomness exists? id say i agree but its an intriguing topic
 
  • +1
Reactions: The Homelander
id say i agree with u

but i have to think about it

i believe the past can be revisited but at that point it will be altered
We're in the past now, but also in the future. The end is the beginning and the beginning is the end
 
time doesn't exist
 
  • +1
Reactions: Youㅤ
We're in the past now, but also in the future. The end is the beginning and the beginning is the end
id have to disagree. our consciousness is only in the present. the past and Future exist but are not energized, at least by our consciousness

the circular idea of time i think is relatively logical. things repeat, things orbit other things. but saying that isnt really clearing anything up.
 
If you believe that the Present can be determined from the Past, but that you can control the Present, then that requires that u can control the Past

so either u believe u have no freewill or ur retarded

if u believe u have no freewill then idc what u say as u have no freewill arguing about freewill which is literally pointless nonsense
How about I nut on your chest faggot
 
  • JFL
Reactions: kyphoscoliosis
"there is no choice" is a retarded notion. common sense tells one there is choice. no model can subtract that, it should build on the foundation of the intuitively known existence of choice.

the amount of implications of "there is no choice" is absurd. generally its good to look at how people behave to assess their beliefs. u nor anyone else i have observed who says "there is no choice" behaves as if they believe they have no choice.

also are u implying that randomness exists? id say i agree but its an intriguing topic
Randomness is the true state of all matter. Everything that can happen will happen, that means that this life is just one line of many possibilities that must play out in only one way. However, all lines lead to the same destination, and we all know what that is
 
  • Hmm...
Reactions: Youㅤ
time doesn't exist
id say i agree, altho that statement is not very descriptive of what does or does not exist specifically. time is emergent from change, which is caused by energy. theres a lot of misconceptions about how people treat time
 
  • Woah
Reactions: Wexilarious
  • JFL
Reactions: yoshisand
id say i agree, altho that statement is not very descriptive of what does or does not exist specifically. time is emergent from change, which is caused by energy. theres a lot of misconceptions about how people treat time
Time is simply distance divided by speed. In other words, movement or entropy. When things move then time is passing
 
  • +1
Reactions: Youㅤ
Randomness is the true state of all matter. Everything that can happen will happen, that means that this life is just one line of many possibilities that must play out in only one way. However, all lines lead to the same destination, and we all know what that is
"anything that can happen will happen"

ill have to think about this. it doesnt make sense except in a very vague way
 
  • +1
Reactions: Toad
Time is simply distance divided by speed. In other words, movement or entropy. When things move then time is passing
This is a scam created from the theory that the earth is spherical and flies in space (like other planets), when in reality it is static and flat
 
  • +1
Reactions: Youㅤ
Time is simply distance divided by speed. In other words, movement or entropy. When things move then time is passing
yes exactly. and things are always moving somewhere so time always exists

but saying time is distance divided by speed is circular reasoning, since speed is distance divided by time :lul:
 
Last edited:
This is a scam created from the theory that the earth is spherical and flies in space (like other planets), when in reality it is static and flat
if it is static and flat, what is the explaination for gravity?
 
  • +1
Reactions: Wexilarious
  • +1
Reactions: Wexilarious
but how is directionality determined?
if earth is flat, u dont think that the earth is accelerating upward to explain gravity?
Always down

I don't know the answer to the second question, although one can make an interesting conclusion that if it worked like that, then dust and everything else would not be able to fly freely in the air
 
  • +1
Reactions: Youㅤ
Always down
i see u have a philosophy based on personal perspective?
I don't know the answer to the second question, although one can make an interesting conclusion that if it worked like that, then dust and everything else would not be able to fly freely in the air
due to the density and weight of the dust, it could. its suspended in air.
 
  • Hmm...
Reactions: Wexilarious
i see u have a philosophy based on personal perspective?

due to the density and weight of the dust, it could. its suspended in air.
I'm only interested in what describes this world more truthfully, so yeah

I can't say for sure, but the density of objects is the only thing that realistically describes how physics works, if it were possible to approach the dome of the earth and get into other similar earths, it would be possible to learn more about this place
 
  • +1
Reactions: Youㅤ

Similar threads

dopercoper
Replies
0
Views
38
dopercoper
dopercoper
Megfish21
Replies
3
Views
139
nuttheb
nuttheb
Youㅤ
Replies
6
Views
83
RXnd
RXnd
evifbus
Replies
9
Views
240
Archimedes
A

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top