SubhumanCurrycel
It’s just hair bro
- Joined
- Feb 28, 2020
- Posts
- 25,623
- Reputation
- 72,511
This is Ignoring the fact that the only attestation we have to it pre-Islam is being a pagan relic with zero oral, written or traditional attestation to Abraham whatsoever prior to Muhammad but we will leave that aside.
The Hadiths claim that Solomons temple and the Kaaba were built 40 years apart
Lets figure out who built Al-aqsa
According to Islam it was Ibrahim/Abraham who built the Kaaba?
In the Quran Abrham argues with a Babylonian king presumably Nimrod putting him around 2000 BC but either way the quran states that David and solomon long descendant from Abraham mean
All Abrahamic traditions maintain that he was the father of Jacob who was the father of the 12 tribes of Israel, from there David or Dawud in Islam is the descendant of the tribe of Judah and King Solomon is his successor. Most genealogies put at the very least 14 generations if not more and logistically at the very least 1000 years between Abraham and David.
David is historically attested to outside of any biblical texts, see the Tel Dan Stele inscribing the House of David. David existed in the early 11th century BC and Solomon his successor must have existed after that.
Again a 1000 year difference in lifetimes yet apparently the buildings were made 40 years apart
.
Either Abraham lived for hundreds of years and continued building or Muhammad saw a pagan building and made shit up.
Now some islamic scholars are smart and they'll say that "NOOOO PROPHET SULAIMAN DID NOT BUILD AL-AQSA HE MERELY RE-BUILT IT!!!" They will then proceed to claim that it was actually Adam who built it and Solomon was merely restoring it.
This is despite he fact that there is zero historical or even islamic source to this claim in the hadith or the Quran, it is arguing backwards after realising how absurd the 40 year claim is.
But lets take it at face value shall we.
Adam was the first of man to exist which would again make him well over 10,000 years old any gap between him and Abraham is magnitudes greater than the gap between Abraham and Solomon. Even if we were to presume a young Earth which is stupid as fuck but why not, Adam and Abraham existed 4000 years apart. Adam was the first of man him, Idris and Nuh according to Islam were notable figures and prophets that existed many years before the flood supposedly, then you have Hud and Saleh who existed after the flood, then much after you get Abraham.
Hence if Adam really built it you once again get a period that is far greater than 40 years and it is clear that Muhammad was just making stuff up as he went.
The Hadiths claim that Solomons temple and the Kaaba were built 40 years apart
Lets figure out who built Al-aqsa
Important to note that Bait Al-Maqdis and Al-Aqsa Mosque are used interchangeably, Bait Al-Maqdis can be referred to the area where al-aqsa resides
Ok so who built the Kaaba?
According to Islam it was Ibrahim/Abraham who built the Kaaba?
And when did Abraham exist?
In the Quran Abrham argues with a Babylonian king presumably Nimrod putting him around 2000 BC but either way the quran states that David and solomon long descendant from Abraham mean
All Abrahamic traditions maintain that he was the father of Jacob who was the father of the 12 tribes of Israel, from there David or Dawud in Islam is the descendant of the tribe of Judah and King Solomon is his successor. Most genealogies put at the very least 14 generations if not more and logistically at the very least 1000 years between Abraham and David.
David is historically attested to outside of any biblical texts, see the Tel Dan Stele inscribing the House of David. David existed in the early 11th century BC and Solomon his successor must have existed after that.
Again a 1000 year difference in lifetimes yet apparently the buildings were made 40 years apart
.Either Abraham lived for hundreds of years and continued building or Muhammad saw a pagan building and made shit up.
Now some islamic scholars are smart and they'll say that "NOOOO PROPHET SULAIMAN DID NOT BUILD AL-AQSA HE MERELY RE-BUILT IT!!!" They will then proceed to claim that it was actually Adam who built it and Solomon was merely restoring it.
This is despite he fact that there is zero historical or even islamic source to this claim in the hadith or the Quran, it is arguing backwards after realising how absurd the 40 year claim is.
But lets take it at face value shall we.
Adam was the first of man to exist which would again make him well over 10,000 years old any gap between him and Abraham is magnitudes greater than the gap between Abraham and Solomon. Even if we were to presume a young Earth which is stupid as fuck but why not, Adam and Abraham existed 4000 years apart. Adam was the first of man him, Idris and Nuh according to Islam were notable figures and prophets that existed many years before the flood supposedly, then you have Hud and Saleh who existed after the flood, then much after you get Abraham.
Hence if Adam really built it you once again get a period that is far greater than 40 years and it is clear that Muhammad was just making stuff up as he went.
