whoishe
Banned
- Joined
- Dec 2, 2024
- Posts
- 1,092
- Reputation
- 1,394
An Assessment of the Decline of Turkish Subforums and the Erosion of Quality
Forums, once one of the most valuable corners of the internet, especially Turkish-speaking subforums, have unfortunately become barren in terms of content and have experienced a significant decline in participant quality. This change did not occur overnight, nor can it be attributed to just one party. It's a decay that has developed over time, and this decay is driven by both user behavior and the evolution of the platforms.
1. The Early Period: Quality, Curiosity, and Sharing
The forum culture that developed from the early 2000s onward thrived primarily on individuals with a certain level of knowledge, a motivation to share, and a background in the "anonymous but respectful" era of the internet. Subforums on topics like technology, literature, games, and philosophy were environments where participants both learned and taught, and even conflicts of opinion were held with a degree of respect.
During these periods, spelling was strictly adhered to, sources were cited, and discussions were argument-based. Trolling was rare because communities were small and familiar. Banning and moderation were more effective. Most importantly, people enjoyed contributing to the forum.
2. Breaking Point: Popularization and the Change of Audience
With the proliferation of the internet, a wider audience joined forums. This democratization was a positive development in theory. However, in practice, the infrastructure and culture of forums were not prepared for this sudden growth. Newcomers were often ignorant of forum etiquette, didn't bother reading, and engaged simply to "make a fuss" or "have fun."
The larger a subforum grows, the lower its average user quality. This is because participation increases, but moderation rates remain the same. Newcomers don't share the discussion ethics valued by the previous generation. Older users either quietly leave or are forced to adapt to the new order. This changes the forum's cultural fabric, and degeneration begins.
3. Current Situation: Toxicity, Vicious Cycle, and Poor Quality
The prevailing atmosphere in many Turkish subforums today: It's frivolity, superficiality, and toxic interactions. The majority of users are no longer there to debate or exchange information, but to satisfy their egos or to taunt others.
Trolling has become normalized. No one is surprised when someone provokes, because this behavior has become the norm, not the exception.
Quality content is penalized. A well-written, well-sourced post is often either unread or ridiculed. However, the simplest, most empty "shitpost" attracts more attention.
Moderators are either incompetent or dysfunctional. They are either biased or simply exhausted.
Community belonging has vanished. People no longer see the forum as their home; instead, they use it as a temporary dumping ground.
The language has degraded. A language where slang is confused with humor and insults are mistaken for "freedom" prevails. Readability has also declined accordingly.
4. Why Did This Happen?
Social media impact: Platforms like Twitter, Reddit, and TikTok have shortened people's patience and attention span. These platforms, diametrically opposed to the "read first, write later" mentality of forum culture, have also transformed forum users.
The collapse of the education system: Analytical thinking, writing skills, and critical thinking are now rare. This directly impacts internet culture.
Cultural degeneration: The simplification of humor, the rise of intellectual laziness, and the normalization of narcissism... These are not unique to the internet; they are a loss of value across society.
The transformation of anonymity into an escape from responsibility: While anonymity used to be a shield for free expression, it is now a cover for aggression and profanity.
5. Is There a Way Out?
Frankly, hoping for a radical improvement at this point is unrealistic. This is because the degeneration isn't limited to one platform; it's the result of a broader digital culture. However, some micro-steps can create small but healthy communities:
Encouraging and making quality content visible
Imposing and enforcing ground rules for participation
A zero-tolerance policy for trolling
Trained moderators
Closed, invitation-only subforums
These can rebuild quality, at least in a small area. But things have already gotten out of hand in larger forums.
@Administrator @chadisbeingmade @Bittersweet @Gengar
Forums, once one of the most valuable corners of the internet, especially Turkish-speaking subforums, have unfortunately become barren in terms of content and have experienced a significant decline in participant quality. This change did not occur overnight, nor can it be attributed to just one party. It's a decay that has developed over time, and this decay is driven by both user behavior and the evolution of the platforms.
1. The Early Period: Quality, Curiosity, and Sharing
The forum culture that developed from the early 2000s onward thrived primarily on individuals with a certain level of knowledge, a motivation to share, and a background in the "anonymous but respectful" era of the internet. Subforums on topics like technology, literature, games, and philosophy were environments where participants both learned and taught, and even conflicts of opinion were held with a degree of respect.
During these periods, spelling was strictly adhered to, sources were cited, and discussions were argument-based. Trolling was rare because communities were small and familiar. Banning and moderation were more effective. Most importantly, people enjoyed contributing to the forum.
2. Breaking Point: Popularization and the Change of Audience
With the proliferation of the internet, a wider audience joined forums. This democratization was a positive development in theory. However, in practice, the infrastructure and culture of forums were not prepared for this sudden growth. Newcomers were often ignorant of forum etiquette, didn't bother reading, and engaged simply to "make a fuss" or "have fun."
The larger a subforum grows, the lower its average user quality. This is because participation increases, but moderation rates remain the same. Newcomers don't share the discussion ethics valued by the previous generation. Older users either quietly leave or are forced to adapt to the new order. This changes the forum's cultural fabric, and degeneration begins.
3. Current Situation: Toxicity, Vicious Cycle, and Poor Quality
The prevailing atmosphere in many Turkish subforums today: It's frivolity, superficiality, and toxic interactions. The majority of users are no longer there to debate or exchange information, but to satisfy their egos or to taunt others.
Trolling has become normalized. No one is surprised when someone provokes, because this behavior has become the norm, not the exception.
Quality content is penalized. A well-written, well-sourced post is often either unread or ridiculed. However, the simplest, most empty "shitpost" attracts more attention.
Moderators are either incompetent or dysfunctional. They are either biased or simply exhausted.
Community belonging has vanished. People no longer see the forum as their home; instead, they use it as a temporary dumping ground.
The language has degraded. A language where slang is confused with humor and insults are mistaken for "freedom" prevails. Readability has also declined accordingly.
4. Why Did This Happen?
Social media impact: Platforms like Twitter, Reddit, and TikTok have shortened people's patience and attention span. These platforms, diametrically opposed to the "read first, write later" mentality of forum culture, have also transformed forum users.
The collapse of the education system: Analytical thinking, writing skills, and critical thinking are now rare. This directly impacts internet culture.
Cultural degeneration: The simplification of humor, the rise of intellectual laziness, and the normalization of narcissism... These are not unique to the internet; they are a loss of value across society.
The transformation of anonymity into an escape from responsibility: While anonymity used to be a shield for free expression, it is now a cover for aggression and profanity.
5. Is There a Way Out?
Frankly, hoping for a radical improvement at this point is unrealistic. This is because the degeneration isn't limited to one platform; it's the result of a broader digital culture. However, some micro-steps can create small but healthy communities:
Encouraging and making quality content visible
Imposing and enforcing ground rules for participation
A zero-tolerance policy for trolling
Trained moderators
Closed, invitation-only subforums
These can rebuild quality, at least in a small area. But things have already gotten out of hand in larger forums.
@Administrator @chadisbeingmade @Bittersweet @Gengar
Last edited:
