
Jaynoyn523
saying something useful.
- Joined
- Aug 11, 2023
- Posts
- 838
- Reputation
- 739
NO TLDR, COC IS BETTER.
1. Strategic Complexity & Cognitive Engagement
Clash of Clans involves:- Base building, troop placement, and long-term resource management.
- Higher-order planning (for example, city layout affects defensive success).
- Asynchronous strategy, players must prepare for attacks they won't see in real time.
- According to cognitive load theory, strategic planning and spatial reasoning improve executive function.
- Games like CoC may better engage the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, responsible for working memory and complex decision-making.
2. Retention and Session Depth
CoC is known for:- Longer session duration.
- Long-term progression systems (Town Hall upgrades, Clan Wars, Builder Base, etc.).
- Based on data from App Annie and Sensor Tower, Clash of Clans tends to have higher long-term retentionrates compared to Clash Royale.
- Clash of Clans has sustained top-grossing charts globally for over a decade.
- Average session time for Clash of Clans: 15–30 minutes/day. (I personally dedicate 30 minutes all the way up to 3 hours a day to the game).
- Clash Royale: 5–10 minutes/day.
3. Community and Clan Dynamics
Clash of Clans encourages:- Clan wars and cooperative planning.
- Shared base designs, attack replays, and long-term team building.
- Cooperative games are more likely to promote community building and sustained engagement.
- According to MMO sociability research, persistent, collaborative environments have a higher social stickiness index than competitive PvP systems like CR.
4. Monetization and Pay-to-Win Balance
Clash of Clans arguably has:- A slower monetization curve.
- More time-based progression instead of instant wins from purchases.
- Games with grindable progress (like CoC) are less likely to trigger pay-to-win frustration.
- Clash Royale has been criticized for “ladder gating” and card-level disadvantages, especially at mid-levels.
5. Educational and Developmental Value
- Clash of Clans encourages planning, delayed gratification, and system-level thinking.
- Clash Royale leans more into quick reflexes and short-term tactical adaptation. (low t fag style of play)
- Long-term planning games foster patience and cognitive flexibility.
- This aligns with findings from studies on delayed gratification and strategic play in children and adolescents (e.g. Mischel's Marshmallow Test correlates).
Summary: Objective Comparison Table
Metric | Clash of Clans | Clash Royale |
---|---|---|
Strategic Depth | Higher | Lower |
Session Length | Longer | Shorter |
Retention Rate | Higher | Moderate |
Social Collaboration | Strong | Moderate |
Pay-to-Win Perception | Lower | Higher |
Cognitive Skills Trained | Planning, Spatial Reasoning, Pattern Recognition. | Quick Reaction, Pattern Recognition |