Dark Souls 1 mogs the fuck out of elden ring

[Hess]

idk how anybody plays elden ring and has fun, open world just is not a good game design choice at all for a soulslike game, shit turns into a shopping list for half the game

 

[literallytaxidriver]

retarded take

 

[Mainlander]

not even a question tbh

its just the second half that ruins it

the first half is literally a 10/10

 

[Hess]

not even a question tbh

its just the second half that ruins it

the first half is literally a 10/10

I really enjoyed the first half up until after raya lucaria, it just turned into a shopping list after that with an open world that just did not compliment the game whatsoever, its a shame because I do really enjoy the story of it

 

[Hess]

retarded take

Why

 

[Krivi.]

idk how anybody plays elden ring and has fun, open world just is not a good game design choice at all for a soulslike game, shit turns into a shopping list for half the game

Both games raises cortisol. Not optimal for living

 

[Hess]

Both games raises cortisol. Not optimal for living

Only raises coritsol if you are bad

 

[Clqs]

Both games raises cortisol. Not optimal for living

 

[Husssu]

not even a question tbh

its just the second half that ruins it

the first half is literally a 10/10

Dark souls 1 is overrated literally 2 and 3 are much better

 

[Hess]

Dark souls 1 is overrated literally 2 and 3 are much better

Yet to play these two yet

 

[Husssu]

Yet to play these two yet

Story gets better alot and gameplay but dark souls 2 is the hardest game I played

 

[Hess]

Story gets better alot and gameplay but dark souls 2 is the hardest game I played

The only time I hear abt ds2 is that you either love it or hate it with all your heart

 

[Med Amine]

After beating the twin knights in ds1 the game becomes kinda mid
Elden only gets better except the ice giant
Elden ring also have like a million weapon too much enemy variety and horsy

 

[Hess]

After beating the twin knights in ds1 the game becomes kinda mid
Elden only gets better except the ice giant
Elden ring also have like a million weapon too much enemy variety and horsy

Elden ring immediately falls off after raya lucaria

 

[Deleted member 439664]

Both games raises cortisol. Not optimal for living

ded srs question i play smash bros a lot but i am shit and take the game too seriously which makes me rage is it really a bad thing ??

 

[Mainlander]

Dark souls 1 is overrated literally 2 and 3 are much better

3 is good

but 2 gets overrated for no reason

its a shit game

 

[Manletsteinberg]

idk how anybody plays elden ring and has fun, open world just is not a good game design choice at all for a soulslike game, shit turns into a shopping list for half the game

Worst take ever

 

[eology]

idk how anybody plays elden ring and has fun, open world just is not a good game design choice at all for a soulslike game, shit turns into a shopping list for half the game

souls like = medieval rolling simulator

 

[Final Fantasy]

Anyone who hasnt played ds 1 will disagree

elden ring is probsbly top 2 most beautiful games ever made though visually

 

[Hess]

Anyone who hasnt played ds 1 will disagree

elden ring is probsbly top 2 most beautiful games ever made though visually

It is a beautiful game, its just extremely shit and flawed in a lot of ways

 

[Centurion Hunter]

idk how anybody plays elden ring and has fun, open world just is not a good game design choice at all for a soulslike game, shit turns into a shopping list for half the game

Agreed

 

[Husssu]

The only time I hear abt ds2 is that you either love it or hate it with all your heart

The game is extremely hard icl I hated it with every might but other than that it's my favorite lol

 

[Husssu]

After beating the twin knights in ds1 the game becomes kinda mid
Elden only gets better except the ice giant
Elden ring also have like a million weapon too much enemy variety and horsy

I agree ngl I like elden ring a bit more cus of the weapon variety and builds u don't have much options in ds 1

 

[Husssu]

3 is good

but 2 gets overrated for no reason

its a shit game

2 is undoubtedly the best in the series only reason to hate it is if ur bad at the game lmao that's why alot of people hate it the difficulty is insane

 

[New Poster]

OP be maidenless

 

[Hess]

I agree ngl I like elden ring a bit more cus of the weapon variety and builds u don't have much options in ds 1

That's not really a great thing when it just turns into being a shopping list for whatever build you are trying to make

 

[Husssu]

That's not really a great thing when it just turns into being a shopping list for whatever build you are trying to make

Ion see it that way I just use whichever random bs I find cool

 

[mrdouchebag]

Dark Souls being the better game is just pure nostalgia.
Maybe it was revolutionary back in 2010 or something.
Elden Ring is the better game, stop coping bro.

 

[verytuffusername]

idk how anybody plays elden ring and has fun, open world just is not a good game design choice at all for a soulslike game, shit turns into a shopping list for half the game

Ds1 is fucking amazing just overused demons imo (ik er has a shit ton of overused bosses)

 

[Futanari]

never ever be soulsborne game as good as ds1. Map, emotion, lore, charachters, aesthetic. best one in all souls games.
My foidless king

 

[Rxndependant]

Overrated lore slop games

 

[Hess]

Overrated lore slop games

Not rly

 

[Hess]

Playing elden ring again, start is AIDs but it really does have strong moments such as stormveil castle and I will admit my scathing on the open world while still there I feel much less against as opposed to now, still not beating DS1 but it is feeling much better than last i played

 

[Throw_Away]

never ever be soulsborne game as good as ds1. Map, emotion, lore, charachters, aesthetic. best one in all souls games.
My foidless king
View attachment 5182654

fuck is that avi nigger

 

[negative]

idk how anybody plays elden ring and has fun, open world just is not a good game design choice at all for a soulslike game, shit turns into a shopping list for half the game

water

 

[Hess]

fuck is that avi nigger

BLAME!

 

[Throw_Away]

idk how anybody plays elden ring and has fun, open world just is not a good game design choice at all for a soulslike game, shit turns into a shopping list for half the game

and then the best soulslike, horsey game walks in and brutally mogs both of them

 

[Hess]

BLAME!

Oh wait you werent replying to me @Throw_Away

 

[Throw_Away]

Oh wait you werent replying to me @Throw_Away

Believe it or not YOURS TRULY has READ blame so I'd RECOGNIZE that avi...

 

[cctslbz]

idk how anybody plays elden ring and has fun, open world just is not a good game design choice at all for a soulslike game, shit turns into a shopping list for half the game

ds1 is barely mentioned anymore and it’s a 5-6/10 now . It gets boring quick and mostly it comes down to preference and Elden ring is better in any aspect but if you re biased and subjective towards ds1 and that’s ur fav game then ds1 gon always be above er . And only way to truly enjoy it past main game is get all achivments and platinum trophy

 

[Hess]

ds1 is barely mentioned anymore and it’s a 5-6/10 now . It gets boring quick and mostly it comes down to preference and Elden ring is better in any aspect but if you re biased and subjective towards ds1 and that’s ur fav game then ds1 gon always be above er . And only way to truly enjoy it past main game is get all achivments and platinum trophy

If you think its a 5-6/10 then you are a normgroid who can't actually meaningfully engage with video games that are somewhat dated, you can't look at the level design and and gameplay loop of ds1 and think ds1 is somehow inferior in all aspects to elden ring jfl

 

[zyzz007 returns]

If you think its a 5-6/10 then you are a normgroid who can't actually meaningfully engage with video games that are somewhat dated, you can't look at the level design and and gameplay loop of ds1 and think ds1 is somehow inferior in all aspects to elden ring jfl

sekiro
mogs
both

 

[cctslbz]

If you think its a 5-6/10 then you are a normgroid who can't actually meaningfully engage with video games that are somewhat dated, you can't look at the level design and and gameplay loop of ds1 and think ds1 is somehow inferior in all aspects to elden ring jfl

I have all the achivments on all soulsborne games including neightrein and des it is a 5-6/10 game and the best game in the series is by far bloodborne then Elden ring then sekiro

 

[cctslbz]

sekiro
mogs
both

tbh sekiro is good but it could of been a lot better and there’s so much more lore to add . Lies of p is better than sekiro

 

[Hess]

I have all the achivments on all soulsborne games including neightrein and des it is a 5-6/10 game and the best game in the series is by far bloodborne then Elden ring then sekiro

Then you have dog shit taste nigga, bloodborne understandable but elden ring is just a shopping list simulator early to mid game and does not beat the atmosphere and gameplay of ds1 at all

 

[DarkAscender]

Old gaem good new game bad ahh take.

How can someone sit here and say game 1 is better. Mind you, the 2nd half is the biggest rushed piece of dogshit there is.

Only thing Dark Souls 1 has over Elden Ring is interconnectivity, and only from start to mid, areas like Tomb of Giants, Blight Town, Lost Izalith are one of the worst in soulsborne and *bed of chaos*.

 

[zyzz007 returns]

tbh sekiro is good but it could of been a lot better and there’s so much more lore to add . Lies of p is better than sekiro

Lies
of
P
parry
isnt
good.

 

[cctslbz]

Then you have dog shit taste nigga, bloodborne understandable but elden ring is just a shopping list simulator early to mid game and does not beat the atmosphere and gameplay of ds1 at all

Nga icba to play ds1 again it has no replayability i got the platinum in 2023 and opened it 1 more time since . And ds2 is better than ds1 . Most souls likes out there are significantly better than ds1 or ds2 and maybe even ds3 . Elden ring is the best because it’s their biggest and most definitive project it barely lacks in any category . Ds1 is the most overrated game and it’s put on a throne like it’s some kind of godly ass game when it’s mid . Most triple A games rn on the market are way better and more enjoyable . Nioh series , lof 1 , mortal Shell , lop mog ds1.
And bloodborne is my fav yeah but i wouldn’t say it’s the best

 

[cctslbz]

Lies
of
P
parry
isnt
good.

It’S better than ok bro , lop parries are harder than sekiro so yeah i can understand but lip worth a try

 

[zyzz007 returns]

It’S better than ok bro , lop parries are harder than sekiro so yeah i can understand but lip worth a try

i
aleady
beat
Lies
of
P,
The
parry
is
too
tight
compared
to
Khazan
and
Sekiro