saumya_19
LTN l 181 CMS
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2024
- Posts
- 547
- Reputation
- 422
At the core, there’s this never ending debate:
Is consciousness just a byproduct of the brain, or is it something more fundamental?
That’s what David Chalmers called the hard problem of consciousness.
You’ve got theories like Integrated Information Theory (IIT) saying that when enough atoms come together in a complex way, consciousness just emerges. Like how H₂O molecules come together and suddenly you get “wetness.”/water
Because wetness is still objective you can measure and explain it. But consciousness is not a physical property but experience.
Atoms aren’t conscious on their own. So how do a bunch of non-conscious things combine and suddenly there’s a witness?
Like right now there’s thoughts, sensations, emotions… but there’s also something that’s aware of them. That silent “observer,” that sense of I am here, experiencing this.
Where does that come from?
When you see red, it’s not just light wavelengths and neurons firing you experience redness.
When someone you care about leaves and you feel that heaviness and
the sense of betrayal
If you say “muh neurons are doing xyz,” and yeah, that explains the mechanism.
But it dodges the central question.
Why is there a first-person perspective at all? Why isn’t all of this just blind processing with no one there to experience it?
Where does this sense of being the witness the one who is aware, the one behind the thoughts even come from?
Is consciousness just a byproduct of the brain, or is it something more fundamental?
That’s what David Chalmers called the hard problem of consciousness.
You’ve got theories like Integrated Information Theory (IIT) saying that when enough atoms come together in a complex way, consciousness just emerges. Like how H₂O molecules come together and suddenly you get “wetness.”/water
Because wetness is still objective you can measure and explain it. But consciousness is not a physical property but experience.
Atoms aren’t conscious on their own. So how do a bunch of non-conscious things combine and suddenly there’s a witness?
Like right now there’s thoughts, sensations, emotions… but there’s also something that’s aware of them. That silent “observer,” that sense of I am here, experiencing this.
Where does that come from?
When you see red, it’s not just light wavelengths and neurons firing you experience redness.
When someone you care about leaves and you feel that heaviness and
the sense of betrayal
If you say “muh neurons are doing xyz,” and yeah, that explains the mechanism.
But it dodges the central question.
Why is there a first-person perspective at all? Why isn’t all of this just blind processing with no one there to experience it?
Where does this sense of being the witness the one who is aware, the one behind the thoughts even come from?
