Frame is more important than height

[veppandi guhan]

 

[Navity]

Name me one person with bad height but a good frame, good height is required for a good frame

 

[LooksOrDeath]

Name me one person with bad height but a good frame, good height is required for a good frame

average height guys usually have better frames

the archetypal ideal of a tall broad shouldered man is rare, theyre usually lanky

 

[LooksOrDeath]

I only agree if you are not more than 3-4 inches shorter

title of the video is complete c0pe

 

[Orc]

they are the same thing, everything increases exponentially with height.

 

[Navity]

average height guys usually have better frames

the archetypal ideal of a tall broad shouldered man is rare, theyre usually lanky

If you are taller your clavicles will look broader and also will be broader.

 

[Orc]

average height guys usually have better frames

the archetypal ideal of a tall broad shouldered man is rare, theyre usually lanky

perceived frame is not the same as actual frame, taller people are broader even when they don't look broader in relationship to their length, it is easy to look wide if your head is tiny, you're short and your torso is small.

 

[LooksOrDeath]

perceived frame is not the same as actual frame, taller people are broader even when they don't look broader in relationship to their length, it is easy to look wide if your head is tiny, you're short and your torso is small.

View attachment 4947748
If you are taller your clavicles will look broader and also will be broader.

I actually do agree
I was saying that shorter guys usually have more dimorphic bodies, but height does make the same 20 inch bidelt look wider on a 6'2 guy than on a 5'8 guy

 

[Orc]

I actually do agree
I was saying that shorter guys usually have more dimorphic bodies, but height does make the same 20 inch bidelt look wider on a 6'2 guy than on a 5'8 guy

the same width looks narrower if you're taller, all features scale up with height and the most dimorphic skeletal feature in men is also height as a result.

 

[LooksOrDeath]

the same width looks narrower if you're taller,

while that should be true on paper, when I stand on my toes my frame does look apparently wider

all features scale up with height and the most dimorphic skeletal feature in men is also height as a result.

I do not think the correlation of height with other dimorphic features is high. Like facial features, bone thickness, penis size etc.

 

[Orc]

I do not think the correlation of height with other dimorphic features is high. Like facial features, bone thickness, penis size etc.

every bone scales up with height.

https://theriaca.co/ANSUR here's a tool where you can compare measurements taken from dudes in the army.

more height = wider bitragion chin arch for example.

 

[LooksOrDeath]

every bone scales up with height.

https://theriaca.co/ANSUR here's a tool where you can compare measurements taken from dudes in the army.

View attachment 4947785

more height = wider bitragion chin arch for example.

The proportions are still the same

for example bidelt width at 170cm seems to be 48cm on average while at 180 it is about 51cm. Same ratio.

most shorter guys i see have thicker bones and wider chests while taller guys are usually lanky

tall guys with dimorphic bodies are rarer

rep me

 

[LooksOrDeath]

every bone scales up with height.

https://theriaca.co/ANSUR here's a tool where you can compare measurements taken from dudes in the army.

View attachment 4947785

more height = wider bitragion chin arch for example.

Actually

to take extreme examples

at 165cm the biacromial width seems to be 40.5cm
at 195cm it is 45cm


That is a difference of about 15% in height, but the shoulder width difference is 11%.

 

[Orc]

The proportions are still the same

perception of an individual without comparison doesn't really mean much, if a tall guy stands to a 'robust' short guy, the short guy still looks small in comparison.

 

[LooksOrDeath]

perception of an individual without comparison doesn't really mean much, if a tall guy stands to a 'robust' short guy, the short guy still looks small in comparison.

rep

 

[LooksOrDeath]

perception of an individual without comparison doesn't really mean much, if a tall guy stands to a 'robust' short guy, the short guy still looks small in comparison.

right but I was not disputing that