Freewill?

[umnresearch]

Do you think freewill exists?

 

[Iasacrko]

Fucking dumb question ofc it doesn't we are a slave to our instincts even the most disciplined of us are only still scratching the barrel of freedom

 

[Iasacrko]

Fucking dumb question ofc it doesn't we are a slave to our instincts even the most disciplined of us are only still scratching the barrel of freedom

Also if you are 100% disciplined and can do anything you want with no limitations you're still not free since we are what we know, for instance a dog isn't free enough to know how to drive a car or play a piano, we as humans are only free to follow the set rules we have.

 

[Deleted member 24627]

If we don't have freewill and all of our "decisions" are merely a continuation of particles interacting with eachother from the start of the big bang, that would mean our consciousness is just watching our lives transpire despite it having no influence on the choices we make.

Why would our consciousness exist if not to implement its will onto the world?

 

[Ragnar]

Also if you are 100% disciplined and can do anything you want with no limitations you're still not free since we are what we know, for instance a dog isn't free enough to know how to drive a car or play a piano, we as humans are only free to follow the set rules we have.

Free will is different from freedom of action, bad argument

Still I agree with your first reply