Ultimate Subhuman™
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2023
- Posts
- 11,530
- Reputation
- 15,860
While the H-1B visa has no official "caste" requirement, studies and social data show that higher-caste individuals are statistically overrepresented among Indian H-1B holders.
This is not due to the visa rules themselves, but rather the result of historical and systemic factors within India that affect who can access the education and professional networks required for U-S. employment.
>
USCIS Rules are Caste-Blind:
The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) does not ask for or consider an applicant's caste. The criteria are purely professional:
>
Education: A bachelor’s degree or higher (or equivalent experience) is required.
Random Lottery: Most H-1B visas are distributed via a random computer-generated lottery.
>
Research (such as the 2020 Indian American Attitudes Survey) indicates that a vast majority of Hindu Indian immigrants in the U.S.—more than 80%—self-identify as belonging to "General" or "Upper" castes. This is disproportionately higher than their percentage of the total population in India.
>
Why Does This Disparity Exist? The concentration of higher-caste Indians in the H-1B pool is generally attributed to:
Access to Elite Education: Admission to top-tier Indian institutions (like IITs or IIMs) and the ability to afford private coaching and English-medium schooling have historically been easier for families with generational wealth and social capital, which often correlates with higher-caste status.
>
Higher-caste individuals often have broader networks in the tech industry and the U.S. diaspora, making it easier to find job opportunities and navigate the complex sponsorship process.
>
Economic Advantage: The process of applying for a master's degree in the U.S. (a common stepping stone to an H-1B) is extremely expensive, often requiring family savings or collateral for loans that many marginalized communities lack.
>
The demographic is slowly changing as more individuals from Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), and Other Backward Classes (OBC) leverage affirmative action in India to gain technical degrees and move into the global workforce.
However, this transition has brought the issue of caste into the U.S. workplace. High-profile legal cases, such as the Cisco lawsuit in 2020, have alleged that caste-based discrimination can follow workers from India to Silicon Valley, leading to calls for "caste" to be added as a protected category in U.S. anti-discrimination laws.
Would you like me to look into the specific U.S. states or companies that have recently updated their policies to address caste discrimination?
This video provides an overview of how Indian IT professionals are viewing the changing landscape of H-1B visas. Indian Tech workers and H-1B visas
Indian Tech workers and H-1B;
This is not due to the visa rules themselves, but rather the result of historical and systemic factors within India that affect who can access the education and professional networks required for U-S. employment.
>
USCIS Rules are Caste-Blind:
The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) does not ask for or consider an applicant's caste. The criteria are purely professional:
>
Education: A bachelor’s degree or higher (or equivalent experience) is required.
Random Lottery: Most H-1B visas are distributed via a random computer-generated lottery.
>
Research (such as the 2020 Indian American Attitudes Survey) indicates that a vast majority of Hindu Indian immigrants in the U.S.—more than 80%—self-identify as belonging to "General" or "Upper" castes. This is disproportionately higher than their percentage of the total population in India.
>
Why Does This Disparity Exist? The concentration of higher-caste Indians in the H-1B pool is generally attributed to:
Access to Elite Education: Admission to top-tier Indian institutions (like IITs or IIMs) and the ability to afford private coaching and English-medium schooling have historically been easier for families with generational wealth and social capital, which often correlates with higher-caste status.
>
Higher-caste individuals often have broader networks in the tech industry and the U.S. diaspora, making it easier to find job opportunities and navigate the complex sponsorship process.
>
Economic Advantage: The process of applying for a master's degree in the U.S. (a common stepping stone to an H-1B) is extremely expensive, often requiring family savings or collateral for loans that many marginalized communities lack.
>
The demographic is slowly changing as more individuals from Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), and Other Backward Classes (OBC) leverage affirmative action in India to gain technical degrees and move into the global workforce.
However, this transition has brought the issue of caste into the U.S. workplace. High-profile legal cases, such as the Cisco lawsuit in 2020, have alleged that caste-based discrimination can follow workers from India to Silicon Valley, leading to calls for "caste" to be added as a protected category in U.S. anti-discrimination laws.
Would you like me to look into the specific U.S. states or companies that have recently updated their policies to address caste discrimination?
This video provides an overview of how Indian IT professionals are viewing the changing landscape of H-1B visas. Indian Tech workers and H-1B visas
Indian Tech workers and H-1B;
Last edited:
