How do you write threads in such a way that gets people to give you legit feedback and critique on music production?

[thecel]

How do you write threads in such a way that gets people to give you legit feedback and critique on music production? I posted a thread asking for music production help in this site. No one helped.

Here’s that thread:

Music-Production-Cels How Do I Make This Sound Better?

I’m trying to make a song like Charlie Puth’s “Light Switch” but my track (attached ITT) sounds shit. Tips?

looksmax.org

 

[thecel]

I’ve seen you sing and it ain’t a pretty sight

I want to get a musician career fr

[SONG] Curlyheadjames x N0rthface - OVER

https://m.soundcloud.com/curlyheadjamessss @curlyheadjames

looksmax.org

The pros in .org don’t teach me how to make good music

 

[thecel]

You can make it bro. Just keep grindsetting

ok but what about real specific advice? I know there’re many music producers here.

How do you write threads in such a way that gets people to give you legit feedback and critique on music production?​

Can you tell me how to write threads that effectively solicit replies? Recently, lots of my threads failed with brutal no-reply-pills even after a few bumps. Why?

 

[AlexBrown84]

This isn’t a music forum why would people know about producing?

 

[Deleted member 18516]

ok but what about real specific advice? I know there’re many music producers here.

How do you write threads in such a way that gets people to give you legit feedback and critique on music production?​

Can you tell me how to write threads that effectively solicit replies? Recently, lots of my threads failed with brutal no-reply-pills even after a few bumps. Why?

View attachment 1616034

It's because no one here knows anything about music, not because of the way you write your threads

 

[thecel]

This isn’t a music forum why would people know about producing?

people here produce :

[SONG] Curlyheadjames x N0rthface - OVER

https://m.soundcloud.com/curlyheadjamessss @curlyheadjames

looksmax.org

 

[Vermilioncore]

unfortunately I only care about my life so sorry bro I don’t give a fuck with all honesty

 

[thecel]

It's because no one here knows anything about music, not because of the way you write your threads

I agree with what Alex brown said not a music forum so people aren’t that interested

how come people gave good feedback before

yet now my threads commonly fail without replies?

The main melody (with the trumpet or whatever the fuck was that) is too quient
Instruments used sound like from a 2004 mexican party mix
The bass is too strong (but I have bass heavy earphones, so maybe its because of that - but still I feel so. In other songs of this type it doesent sound so strong) - making it sound like some rap beat
The guitar is too quiet, just cant just use a guitar riff at the volume as everything else
Feels a bit too busy at times

Pretty spot on. I think you need to look at the kick, it has this thump which like RnB but it's not nice and unlike original. Also snare should be different imo.

Not enough 808s and distortion.

Am I going to shit, or is the forum going to shit?

How does a poster determine whether the forum is going shit or he’s going shit?

What’re some methods to figure out whether decreases in a poster’s threads’ popularities are caused by a declining forum or worsening quality in his content?

looksmax.org

 

[Deleted member 18516]

how come people gave good feedback before

yet now my threads commonly fail without replies?







Am I going to shit, or is the forum going to shit?

How does a poster determine whether the forum is going shit or he’s going shit?

What’re some methods to figure out whether decreases in a poster’s threads’ popularities are caused by a declining forum or worsening quality in his content?

looksmax.org

those users are probalbly not active anymore on this forum

 

[Salieri]

Why are you looking for music advice on looksmax

 

[thecel]

those users are probalbly not active anymore on this forum

Forum’s going shit. Brutal.

 

[thecel]

Why are you looking for music advice on looksmax

because I’m making Looksmax-related music

 

[Salieri]

because I’m making Looksmax-related music

What does that have to do with seeking advice on the actual quality of the music itself

0 correlation

post a snippit or something rn

 

[thecel]

What does that have to do with seeking advice on the actual quality of the music itself

0 correlation

post a snippit or something rn

 

[Mongrelcel]

Am I going to shit, or is the forum going to shit?

like he said, people don't know about music other than just saying "it's fire"
writing actual constructive criticism requires thinking, and that's hard, so people don't do it