Seth Walsh
Iconoclast
Contributor
- Joined
- Jan 12, 2020
- Posts
- 11,032
- Reputation
- 22,545
Liberal Millennials Are Finally Having Midlife Crises
There is something extremely funny happening to the urban liberal millennial.For roughly 15 years, an entire professional-class subculture managed to convert economic stagnation into a personality.
Now they're approaching 35–45 and some of the coping mechanisms are beginning to expire.
Not everyone, obviously. I'm talking about a very specific archetype.
You know him.
He's 38. Works in the same broadly interchangeable corporate job he's had since 2016. Has changed companies four times but somehow remained on exactly the same rung of the class hierarchy.
He rents a room in a house with Alan, Max, Other Max, Australian Max, Sarah, Sarah's boyfriend and some bloke nobody has actually seen since February.
But don't worry.
He's living his best life.
1. Renting became an ideology
At 27:At 31:
At 35:
At 39:
Meanwhile his landlord bought the property in 2009 and has been quietly converting his salary into equity for fifteen years.
The greatest millennial cope wasn't avocado toast.
It was convincing themselves that not owning capital was somehow spiritually superior to owning capital.
The landlord wasn't doing discourse.
The landlord was compounding.
2. "Experiences" replaced accumulation
This generation became obsessed with experiences.Bali.
Berlin.
Lisbon.
Vietnam.
Thailand.
A festival in Croatia.
A six-week sabbatical because "I just needed to reset."
There is nothing wrong with travelling.
The cope appears when consumption gets rhetorically upgraded into capital.
€5,000 disappears.
But you didn't spend €5,000.
You "invested in memories."
Twenty years later the memories are lovely.
The €5,000 invested into productive assets at 28 would also have produced some fairly lovely memories.
Possibly involving a house.
3. Hobbies became substitute progression
Climbing.Running clubs.
Gaming.
CrossFit.
Craft beer.
Coffee.
Photography.
Festivals.
Fantasy football.
Cycling.
Dungeons & Dragons.
A podcast nobody listens to.
Again: hobbies are good.
But there is an enormous difference between:
"I have hobbies because my life is progressing."
and
"My hobbies are where I go so I don't have to notice my life isn't progressing."
You can become incredibly busy without actually moving anywhere.
That distinction becomes harder to ignore at 40.
4. Alcohol was rebranded as personality
Millennial drinking culture deserves its own anthropological study.Nobody was drinking because they were bored, lonely or stressed.
They were:
"into natural wine."
"checking out a new brewery."
"doing bottomless brunch."
"meeting the gang for a few."
Every coping mechanism becomes respectable once you give it sufficiently expensive branding.
Four pints after work because you hate your job = depressing.
Four €8.50 IPAs because you're exploring Dublin's craft beer scene = culture.
5. Career stagnation was disguised by job-title inflation
This one is brutal.Analyst.
Senior Analyst.
Associate.
Senior Associate.
Manager.
Senior Manager.
Lead.
Head of Something Nobody Can Explain.
Your title changed six times.
Your relationship to capital didn't change once.
You're still selling labour.
Your employer still owns the productive system.
Your landlord still owns the house.
Your pension fund owns the equities.
Your bank owns the debt.
You own a standing desk and 14,000 LinkedIn connections.
The modern professional class became extremely sophisticated at measuring career movement without measuring balance-sheet movement.
6. Politics became psychological hedging
This is where it gets interesting.Political identity can become a way of narrating your personal economic position without confronting it directly.
If you're 37, renting, have limited savings and feel further from family formation than you expected, there are two psychologically available stories.
Story A:
Story B:
The second story may contain a lot of truth.
Housing genuinely became less affordable.
Asset prices genuinely outran wages.
The post-2008 economy genuinely produced horrible intergenerational timing effects.
But structural explanations can simultaneously be true and psychologically useful.
Politics becomes cope when explanation turns into absolution from strategy.
You can correctly identify a broken housing system and still need somewhere to live.
7. "I don't want kids anyway"
Maybe you genuinely don't.Fine.
But there is an obvious cultural pattern where preferences mysteriously adapt to whatever has become financially inaccessible.
House too expensive?
"I prefer renting."
Car too expensive?
"Cars are terrible for cities."
Children economically difficult?
"I never really wanted them."
Marriage delayed indefinitely?
"Marriage is an outdated institution."
Career plateaued?
"I don't live to work."
Wealth unavailable?
"Money doesn't make you happy."
Human beings are unbelievably good at transforming constraints into preferences.
It protects the ego.
It also makes constraints harder to solve.
8. Doomscrolling created simulated agency
This might be the funniest part.Hours per week spent reading about:
Trump.
Brexit.
Musk.
Climate.
Boomers.
Landlords.
AI.
Capitalism.
Late-stage capitalism.
Whatever Elon tweeted at 2:17am.
You feel politically engaged.
You feel informed.
You feel like you're participating in enormous historical forces.
Meanwhile your actual personal balance sheet has moved €14 since Tuesday.
Modern media gives people the sensation of agency while extracting attention from the tiny number of variables over which they actually possess agency.
Income.
Savings.
Ownership.
Skills.
Location.
Relationships.
Health.
Time.
9. The midlife crisis arrives when optionality collapses
At 25, nearly every future remains imaginable.You could move abroad.
Change career.
Start a company.
Get married.
Buy a house.
Become wealthy.
Have children.
Completely reinvent yourself.
This creates psychological optionality even when you aren't actually exercising any options.
Then time passes.
That's when the crisis starts.
Not because 40 is old.
Because path dependence becomes visible.
The choices you repeatedly made at 27, 29, 31 and 34 have now become your circumstances.
Your life has acquired inertia.
10. Social class was accumulating quietly the entire time
This is the part millennials were culturally terrible at understanding.Class isn't just salary.
It's:
income + assets + family capital + housing position + partner economics + inheritance expectations + occupational security + network access + time.
Two people earning €70k can inhabit completely different social classes.
Person A:
Owns property.
Partner earns €60k.
Parents own assets.
€150k invested.
Low housing costs.
Strong professional network.
Person B:
Rents.
Single income.
Parents rent.
€8k savings.
High fixed costs.
No meaningful assets.
Same salary.
Completely different trajectory.
Because class compounds.
11. The real divide wasn't "boomers vs millennials"
It increasingly became:people connected to appreciating assets vs people permanently paying them.
Owners watched housing and equities compound.
Non-owners watched wages compound much more slowly.
Then ownership itself became hereditary.
Parents help with deposits.
Parents provide housing.
Parents transfer businesses.
Parents fund education.
Parents eventually transfer estates.
Suddenly two supposedly identical 35-year-old professionals diverge massively.
One receives €200k.
The other receives nothing.
The spreadsheet does not care that both enjoy oat milk.
12. And this is why the millennial midlife crisis is going to be spectacular
The classic midlife crisis was:The millennial midlife crisis is increasingly:
Travel wasn't ownership.
Consumption wasn't wealth.
A job title wasn't capital.
Political awareness wasn't agency.
Being busy wasn't progression.
Renting wasn't freedom forever.
Experiences weren't a pension.
Doomscrolling wasn't participation.
Therapy vocabulary wasn't a balance sheet.
And "I'm only 30" eventually becomes "how the fuck am I 41?"
That doesn't mean millennials uniquely failed.
They entered adulthood through the financial crisis, housing scarcity, collapsing affordability and extraordinary asset-price inflation.
They were dealt a strange hand.
But the cultural response was often even stranger:
instead of admitting that ownership and class mattered enormously, they developed an elaborate moral vocabulary explaining why everything they couldn't obtain was actually cringe anyway.
Now the first large cohort is entering middle age.
The avocado toast jokes were never really about avocado toast.
They were about a generation trying to build an identity around life without capital while capital was quietly determining more and more of everyone's life.
The coping phase is ending.
The compounding phase isn't.
