garoutheincelReturn
Iron
- Joined
- Jul 18, 2023
- Posts
- 37
- Reputation
- 20
Gulfoids b
I am a pashtun from kpk , our identity as pashtun is afghan and we are not in the minority , every single tribe leader will tell you pashtun and afghan are inter-changeable words. The a in Pakistan even stands for AfghaniaThe reason these things don’t take place in Punjabi-dominated places is because Punjab is located in East Pakistan, whereas Balochistan and the rest are located in West Pakistan. West Pakistan borders Afghanistan and Afghanistan has been a stronghold for terrorists such as al-Qaeda, TTP, et cetera. That explains why it happens mostly in West Pakistan. It has nothing to do with ethnic groups, that’s just an agenda that people have because they want to claim Pakistani land as their own or because they want to see Pakistanis having an ethno-nationalistic rivalry against each other so that Pakistan destroys itself from within rather than having their own army or armies doing it. Saves them the trouble.
Historically speaking, parts of NWFP was held by Indic peoples whereas Iranic peoples migrated in later centuries. If these Iranic peoples don’t want to be a part of Pakistan, I don’t have a problem with that - but they should just move to Afghanistan if that’s what they desire, instead of trying to take lands that wasn’t theirs to begin with. It’s alright to stay there, however, if they want to be a part of Pakistan.
Also, you’re going off of a lot of propaganda here, because you’re mentioning Bengalis. That was carried out by Mukti Bahini, a militia group created, trained and funded by Bharat - and their crimes were blamed on the Pakistani army, which is false. Therefore I cannot take any videos of yours as evidence as it shows you have already fallen for propaganda before and the chances are high that you are showing me more propaganda.
Furthermore most Afghans - I assume you’re Afghan - claim to hate the Pakistani state but they also hate Pakistani people, so they’re usually deceiving. I would have liked Afghans more if they weren’t so hateful towards us.
Or you’re a Pakistani who thinks he’s Afghan? I’ve met a few of those, but they have always been a minority. Their dreams of having their own country while taking Pakistani lands is nothing but a fever dream. As I said before, they are more than welcome to move to Afghanistan, but they aren’t allowed to take lands that didn’t historically belong to them. I think this is a fair approach, don’t you think?
I wouldn't want to be part of current day afghanistan rather have our own pashtunistan however it's more feasible with the rise of the IEA to become part of Afghanistan since they hold the same pashtun Islamic values we do and do not commit crimes like the punjabis have done to kpk and waziristan.
There is an ethnic war we couldn't even speak pashto in our universities without being fined.
More over if you looked into the history we were promised autonomy over our own lands, pashtuns had instated shariah law as per malakand yousufzia since the 1500s