GonorrhoeaGobbler
Follow my footsteps — our paths shall never cross.
- Joined
- Nov 11, 2025
- Posts
- 13,484
- Reputation
- 22,954
[1]: He’s old enough to have been Mr Cruel. Mr Cruel was described as being either in his 20s or 30s, and Scully, born in 1963, would’ve been in his mid-20s when Mr Cruel was active.
[2]: Most of his abducted victims were a similar age to Mr Cruel’s, with his significant exception being an 18-month-old baby.
[3]: He absolutely fits the moniker of “Super cool and super cruel”.
[4]: Mr Cruel was described as being soft-spoken and unhurried, and Scully was disturbingly soft-spoken and unhurried during his interviews and arrest.
[5]: He filmed his victims for his dark web child pornography business, No Limits Fun. Mr Cruel similarly possibly filmed his victims, as Sharon Wills recalled a wooden tripod stand being at the foot of the bed she was tied to, and even the FBI's profile of Mr Cruel states that he likely kept recordings of his victims.
[6]: After being apprehended, a fire broke out in the evidence room holding Scully's sieged laptop and videos. Some believe Scully was responsible for this by bribing a local police officer to set the evidence room alight in order to destroy any and all evidence against him. Likewise, Mr Cruel was obviously very preoccupied about the prospect of leaving any possible evidence, and vigorously ensured that no such evidence was left behind to link him to his crimes.
[7]: He abducted victims and brought them back to his lair/base to carry out his acts. We know Mr Cruel similarly did this with at least 2 of his canonical victims, Sharon and Lynas, but likely Karmein as well if she was a victim of Mr Cruel.
[8]: He murdered (or there’s roughly a 99.99% chance that it was him given he filmed himself doing it) an abducted 11-year-old girl, Cindy, in 2012, who appeared in the No Limits Fun films. Likewise, Mr Cruel murdered Karmein Chan after abducting her (although, to reiterate once again, opinions are divided on if Mr Cruel was Karmein's abductor). Albeit Scully strangled his victim with a rope rather than shooting her like Mr Cruel did.
Biggest things that I could find at this point against Scully being Mr Cruel is that, prior to fleeing to the Philippines, he lived in Narre Warren, far from North-East Melbourne where Mr Cruel's hideout most likely was. However, that doesn't mean that's where he lived indefinitely, as he could've moved to Narre Warren at any point in his life. On top of this, he was married and had 2 children, and it would be hard for a potential Mrs Cruel, or in this case Mrs Scully, not to know about her husband's antics. But likewise, I can't find anything recording specifically when he got married, meaning it could've been after Mr Cruel's activity.
I'm not saying Peter Scully is Mr Cruel, but surely he must've been investigated by someone at some point as a possible suspect.
[2]: Most of his abducted victims were a similar age to Mr Cruel’s, with his significant exception being an 18-month-old baby.
[3]: He absolutely fits the moniker of “Super cool and super cruel”.
[4]: Mr Cruel was described as being soft-spoken and unhurried, and Scully was disturbingly soft-spoken and unhurried during his interviews and arrest.
[5]: He filmed his victims for his dark web child pornography business, No Limits Fun. Mr Cruel similarly possibly filmed his victims, as Sharon Wills recalled a wooden tripod stand being at the foot of the bed she was tied to, and even the FBI's profile of Mr Cruel states that he likely kept recordings of his victims.
[6]: After being apprehended, a fire broke out in the evidence room holding Scully's sieged laptop and videos. Some believe Scully was responsible for this by bribing a local police officer to set the evidence room alight in order to destroy any and all evidence against him. Likewise, Mr Cruel was obviously very preoccupied about the prospect of leaving any possible evidence, and vigorously ensured that no such evidence was left behind to link him to his crimes.
[7]: He abducted victims and brought them back to his lair/base to carry out his acts. We know Mr Cruel similarly did this with at least 2 of his canonical victims, Sharon and Lynas, but likely Karmein as well if she was a victim of Mr Cruel.
[8]: He murdered (or there’s roughly a 99.99% chance that it was him given he filmed himself doing it) an abducted 11-year-old girl, Cindy, in 2012, who appeared in the No Limits Fun films. Likewise, Mr Cruel murdered Karmein Chan after abducting her (although, to reiterate once again, opinions are divided on if Mr Cruel was Karmein's abductor). Albeit Scully strangled his victim with a rope rather than shooting her like Mr Cruel did.
Biggest things that I could find at this point against Scully being Mr Cruel is that, prior to fleeing to the Philippines, he lived in Narre Warren, far from North-East Melbourne where Mr Cruel's hideout most likely was. However, that doesn't mean that's where he lived indefinitely, as he could've moved to Narre Warren at any point in his life. On top of this, he was married and had 2 children, and it would be hard for a potential Mrs Cruel, or in this case Mrs Scully, not to know about her husband's antics. But likewise, I can't find anything recording specifically when he got married, meaning it could've been after Mr Cruel's activity.
I'm not saying Peter Scully is Mr Cruel, but surely he must've been investigated by someone at some point as a possible suspect.
