My beef with HDR in smartphones

Which picture do you prefer


  • Total voters
    6
Jason Voorhees

Jason Voorhees

๐•ธ๐–Š๐–—๐–ˆ๐–Š๐–“๐–†๐–—๐–ž ๐•ฎ๐–”๐–—๐–• โ€ข ๐Ÿ๐ŸŽ๐Ÿ๐Ÿ’๐Ÿฅ‡
Joined
May 15, 2020
Posts
96,613
Reputation
293,621
I already made a thread explaining how computational photography works and singing praises about it


But I have one small problem with this. It is HDR. HDR tries to merge multiple exposures so both the dark and bright areas look "perfect." In real life this is not possible because obviously you will have shadows and varying exposures because we only have one sun as a source of white light

And that's why it is a problem. nothing irl is supposed to be perfect. In real life, shadows give depth and atmosphere. When the phone lifts every dark corner and tones down every highlight, you lose the natural texture and contrast that gives a photo emotion. It's like turning every moody sunset or dramatic light into a wallpaper some painting or whatever

HDR processing also often boosts saturation, loses depth. I get that most people want punchy, social media feady photos but it should have some resemblence to real life. What do you think? Which picture is better? I took them


Picture 1

1000109140


Picture 2

1000111754
b
 
  • +1
Reactions: Deleted member 165274, browncurrycel, Deleted member 244159 and 2 others
First picture is better, I like the realistic image.

For social media you can just get a proper handheld camera.

The Canon Powershot is a popular option.
 
  • +1
Reactions: Mogger, browncurrycel, Embryo and 1 other person
Picture 1 looks clearer and overall better. Picture 2 looks like the exposure was raised higher than it needed to be.
 
  • +1
Reactions: browncurrycel, Jason Voorhees and Deleted member 244159
More votes needed
 
@childishkillah
 
I already made a thread explaining how computational photography works and singing praises about it


But I have one small problem with this. It is HDR. HDR tries to merge multiple exposures so both the dark and bright areas look "perfect." In real life this is not possible because obviously you will have shadows and varying exposures because we only have one sun as a source of white light

And that's why it is a problem. nothing irl is supposed to be perfect. In real life, shadows give depth and atmosphere. When the phone lifts every dark corner and tones down every highlight, you lose the natural texture and contrast that gives a photo emotion. It's like turning every moody sunset or dramatic light into a wallpaper some painting or whatever

HDR processing also often boosts saturation, loses depth. I get that most people want punchy, social media feady photos but it should have some resemblence to real life. What do you think? Which picture is better? I took them


Picture 1

View attachment 4266195

Picture 2

View attachment 4266198b

1
 

Similar threads

AscendHQ
Replies
9
Views
61
AscendHQ
AscendHQ
inyerta
Replies
1
Views
31
salludonlite--
salludonlite--
Thodian
Replies
1
Views
32
Thodian
Thodian
Mansur
Replies
6
Views
122
MangoLover
MangoLover
Jason5000
Replies
17
Views
106
HappyChud
HappyChud

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top