reptiles
gymcel or death
- Joined
- May 19, 2019
- Posts
- 35,522
- Reputation
- 31,382
Argument 1 It's a highly selected population from India with higher amount of polymorphisms correlated in some studies to measured indicators of intellegence issues with this ? polygenic scores have low replication rates, they are notoriously bound for false positives in other words it can set an expectation but that expectation often is wrong on top of that due to a larger focus and decades of research poured into European bio banks the SNP correlates are higher in whites than Indian populations.
Even if it was all genetics it wouldn't mean much because genetics is a result of your epigenetic factors writing down numbers like an IQ of 115 or an IQ of 130 means jack shit if they can't find replication in the real world you have plenty of smart mensa people who achieve very little in life so again this metric isn't accurate.
Argument 2 They picked the smartest of that population to transport to the US. Issues with that ? well okay if they picked the smartest of there pops that doesn't explain why there children do so well as well it doesn't even address why the wealth of curries only continues to rise.
So what is the actual reason indians are doing well in the US ? simple they work harder and they study harder on top of that they make use of there motor functions at a younger age this is the real reason why Indians so so well in the US.
They do shit in India because most of the population is malnourished, on top of that the access to education is lower which again correlates the strongest to long term income through work as no 1 will higher an non skilled worker for a engineering task or a architect task. Added to that there is a lot of corruption and nepotism.
But the biggest indicator of familial success unless you have a disability is a hard work ethic from a younger age.
Even if it was all genetics it wouldn't mean much because genetics is a result of your epigenetic factors writing down numbers like an IQ of 115 or an IQ of 130 means jack shit if they can't find replication in the real world you have plenty of smart mensa people who achieve very little in life so again this metric isn't accurate.
Argument 2 They picked the smartest of that population to transport to the US. Issues with that ? well okay if they picked the smartest of there pops that doesn't explain why there children do so well as well it doesn't even address why the wealth of curries only continues to rise.
So what is the actual reason indians are doing well in the US ? simple they work harder and they study harder on top of that they make use of there motor functions at a younger age this is the real reason why Indians so so well in the US.
They do shit in India because most of the population is malnourished, on top of that the access to education is lower which again correlates the strongest to long term income through work as no 1 will higher an non skilled worker for a engineering task or a architect task. Added to that there is a lot of corruption and nepotism.
But the biggest indicator of familial success unless you have a disability is a hard work ethic from a younger age.