[POLL] Is the Blackpiller (Scribe) in this Debate Right or Wrong, and Did He Win or Lose the Debate?

[thecel]

Is the Blackpiller (Scribe) in this Debate Right or Wrong, and Did He Win or Lose the Debate?

Debate Performance Outcomes	Incorrect Points	Correct Points
Bad Debate Skills	You lose the debate because your claims are ridiculous.	You lose the debate because you fail to argue your points effectively even though they’re correct.
Good Debate Skills	You win the debate with your rhetoric, charisma, and/or tactics, but your claims aren’t logically true.	You win the debate with good argumentation skills that bolster correct claims.

---

IMO, whether you (dis)agree with Scribe doesn’t matter; you should support his arguments regardless, just to be dogmatically locked into the blackpill.

Daily Reminder: The Natural Tendency of Humans Is to Move Toward BLUEPILL

I love the vibe of darkhard incelmaxed gigaconservative blackpill worldviews, but convincing normies of your darkhard incelmaxed gigaconservative blackpill positions is damn near impossible. Just watch the super blackpiller ( Smash TV ) looking like an utter dumbass brainlet arguing for his...

looksmax.org

 

[khvirgin]

 

[thecel]

View attachment 2200384

as if you don’t consoom content for hours

just find some time in your daily time-wasting schedule to watch it

 

[Deleted member 14693]

Haven't watched the full video but in the part I skipped to he claims that its impossible for the hoster to have a girlfriend.

Which is just straight up delusion so he lost

 

[thecel]

View attachment 2200384

@Beastimmung

Here’s a time when I think Scribe utterly failed his position in the debate:

 

[Deleted member 21661]

@Beastimmung

Here’s a time when I think Scribe utterly failed his position in the debate:

I don't think they won the point because talking about one's personal experience means anything
Out of 7 billion people there will naturally be exceptions to experience
Rhetoric, reasoning, or statistics > experience claims

He claimed he slept with 300 women
How do we know he's telling the truth? What about money? What were the ratings of these girls? Over what time period is this? What's his height? Did he geomaxx?

 

[Deleted member 29274]

who cares

 

[khvirgin]

as if you don’t consoom content for hours

just find some time in your daily time-wasting schedule to watch it

I'd rather drink bleach than watch a bunch of losers talk for 4 hours

 

[Ryan]

Is the Blackpiller (Scribe) in this Debate Right or Wrong, and Did He Win or Lose the Debate?

Debate Performance Outcomes	Incorrect Points	Correct Points
Bad Debate Skills	You lose the debate because your claims are ridiculous.	You lose the debate because you fail to argue your points effectively even though they’re correct.
Good Debate Skills	You win the debate with your rhetoric, charisma, and/or tactics, but your claims aren’t logically true.	You win the debate with good argumentation skills that bolster correct claims.

---

IMO, whether you (dis)agree with Scribe doesn’t matter; you should support his arguments regardless, just to be dogmatically locked into the blackpill.

Daily Reminder: The Natural Tendency of Humans Is to Move Toward BLUEPILL

I love the vibe of darkhard incelmaxed gigaconservative blackpill worldviews, but convincing normies of your darkhard incelmaxed gigaconservative blackpill positions is damn near impossible. Just watch the super blackpiller ( Smash TV ) looking like an utter dumbass brainlet arguing for his...

looksmax.org

I DIDNT SAW THE DEBATE AND WILL NOT BUT

 

[thecel]

I don't think they won the point because talking about one's personal experience means anything
Out of 7 billion people there will naturally be exceptions to experience
Rhetoric, reasoning, or statistics > experience claims

He claimed he slept with 300 women
How do we know he's telling the truth? What about money? What were the ratings of these girls? Over what time period is this? What's his height? Did he geomaxx?

You should accept it as the truth because sleeping around is so fucking common in modern society that not having at least a 2-digit body count is a huge exception.

 

[Deleted member 21661]

You should accept it as the truth because sleeping around is so fucking common in modern society that not having a 3-digit body count is a huge exception.

If that's the case it means even less.
Neither of the sides have real points (in such debates) because of such debates
The way an argument goes is:

Blackpillers posts statistics about dating apps related to height, race, swiping statistics, etc
Bluepiller or redpiller says that dating apps aren't real life and on there people only see pictures, it's geared towards shallow people, or bad gender ratio

Which may be understandable arguments, and of course some are objectively true like the gender ratio, but you can't really use such statistics in real life cases, there's no swiping in real life and statistics would only represent self reported surveys rather than actual actions (such as swipe statistics and filters)
But such surveys are inherently biased because people often lie on these, including to themselves

So what exactly is the solution?

muh redpill vs blackpill debate just seems pointless to me

How would you conduct one? With what purpose?

 

[AspiringMogger]

Debate Performance Outcomes	Incorrect Points	Correct Points
Bad Debate Skills	You lose the debate because your claims are ridiculous.	You lose the debate because you fail to argue your points effectively even though they’re correct.
Good Debate Skills	You win the debate with your rhetoric, charisma, and/or tactics, but your claims aren’t logically true.	You win the debate with good argumentation skills that bolster correct claims.

he had incorrect points and bad debate skills. He got easily agitated and couldn’t coherently string a point together. When you are 1v5’ing goofy redpillers you have to stay calm.

He also made absurd claims: “Idk if you’ve had a girlfriend”. Also just other things such as refuting the host Alex’es bodycount being 300 which i think is a good thing, but it just came off as salty because of his poor debate skills.

 

[Deleted member 22918]

Dnw

But i used to watch Mgtow Dictionary stream every week so i know scribe is really bad at debating

 

[Crusile]

I will watch this 3 your video to vote in thread poll seems legit