Standardizing BOTB criteria

[Alexanderr]

Up until now BOTB threads have been added on a rather arbitrary basis so I want to standardize and objective the procedure somewhat. So at the very least people know what they have to aim for.
Any suggestions as to what should be necessary for a thread to be considered BOTB?

There's also the fact that there are duplicate threads in the BOTB currently. So I want to get rid of the worse ones and leave the best.

Link some threads you think should or shouldn't be in the BOTB and explain why.

 

[LiteralCaucasian]

I liked your old profile picture more.

 

[Tabula Rasa]

Community vetting procedure for BOTB threads

 

[Bakin donuts 🍩]