Who is the highest IQ user on ORG?

[Ogionth]

I have not claimed either side, that's the whole point.

Where did I claim that 271k was the exact figure?

Why would I call it a controversy if I
believed 271k was the exact number? I said there were two claims and I affirmed neither.

If you show me, I will delete my org account.

It seems as if you're just arguing without even reading my texts.

Btw you're also ignoring the Jewish migration to

1. USSR (300k to 500k)

2. Latin America

3. UK

4. US

which makes your claim of 3.5M jews even more absurd to affirm the 6 million and on what census was the Germany number based?


I claimed neither, while you claimed 6M despite it being so deviated from the population count that it is logically impossible to kill 6M out of 3.5M Jews even if we ignore the migrations stated above.

My position is far stronger than yours and it's absurd that you even are arguing about this.

 

[Сигма Бой]

I have not claimed either side, that's the whole point.

Where did I claim that 271k was the exact figure in this specific argument?

Why would I call it a controversy if I
believed 271k was the exact number? I said there were two claims and I affirmed neither.

If you show me, I will delete my org account.

It seems as if you're just arguing without even reading my texts.

It'z exactly 271,301.

 

[Snicket]

I have not claimed either side, that's the whole point.

Where did I claim that 271k was the exact figure?

Why would I call it a controversy if I
believed 271k was the exact number? I said there were two claims and I affirmed neither.

If you show me, I will delete my org account.

It seems as if you're just arguing without even reading my texts.

I didn’t mean to attribute 271K to you - that was a mistake.
I suppose I disagree with your point that there is not enough census data.

I don’t really want to debate this topic.

 

[Ogionth]

I suppose I disagree with your point that there is not enough census data.

I don’t really want to debate this topic.

Ok let's suppose there is enough census data.

then as you claimed, the population is 3.5M, you're literally going against logic itself to affirm the 6 million count even when ignoring the confirmed migration counts to USSR, Latin America, US, UK, Mandatory Palestine and so on.


How do you kill 6 million people out of 3.5 million?

This is quite illogical, don't you think so?

 

[Snicket]

Btw you're also ignoring the Jewish migration to

1. USSR (300k to 500k)

2. Latin America

3. UK

4. US

which makes your claim of 3.5M jews even more absurd to affirm the 6 million and on what census was the Germany number based?


I claimed neither, while you claimed 6M despite it being so deviated from the population count that it is logically impossible to kill 6M out of 3.5M Jews even if we ignore the migrations stated above.

My position is far stronger than yours and it's absurd that you even are arguing about this.

I never claimed 6 million, I said I was skeptical of the lower end figure - like I said.

You’re doing the very thing you accused me of.

I don’t wish to debate this topic. I felt cursory research on this undermines the idea that millions didn’t die.

 

[Snicket]

Ok let's suppose there is enough census data.

then as you claimed, the population is 3.5M, you're literally going against logic itself to affirm the 6 million count even when ignoring the confirmed migration counts.

How do you kill 6 million people out of 3.5 million?

That’s just in Poland alone. I said I was skeptical of the lower end figure - that is all.

 

[Ogionth]

I never claimed 6 million, I said I was skeptical of the lower end figure - like I said.

You’re doing the very thing you accused me of.

I don’t wish to debate this topic. I felt cursory research on this undermines the idea that millions didn’t die.

Saying that you were skeptical of the lower figure has a hidden presupposition that you're not AS skeptical of the upper one.

So in other words, you're more skeptical of the logical possibility than the logical impossibility (considering your own population counts) which is asburd.

I'm not doing the thing, that you did.

I'm using basic inference from logicality.

 

[Ogionth]

That’s just in Poland alone. I said I was skeptical of the lower end figure - that is all.

"There were around 500K Jews in Germany and 3 million in Poland"

- Snicket.


I guess we all should start making shit up and then put a disclaimer later

 

[Snicket]

"There were around 500K Jews in Germany and 3 million in Poland"

- Snicket.


I guess we all should start making shit up and then put a disclaimer later

I’d like to do more research before I could come to a proper conclusion about the figures

I based that my figures off the Polish census from 1931 that put the Jewish population above 3 million.

I am not well informed about this. My basic point was that initial figures did make the lower end less credible to me - that is all.

That does not mean I beleive the upper end by default.

 

[Ogionth]

My basic point was that initial figures did make the lower end less credible to me - that is all.

I mean, disregard everything that was said (since you said that, there's not enough research done and it was based upon cursory info) and let's talk about something other than that.

How is a logical impossibility is more credible to you than a logical possibility?

 

[goober55]

test me with a riddle or something

 

[gookcelriceR]

@_MVP_ is my only honest answer. People joke because they don’t understand his threads, but he is a very intelligent man. The simplicity of his threads hides the painstaking thought and deduction that was put into them, much like the Ancient Greeks hid the Analysis in their geometry. Having read MVP threads since the lookism days though, I know each one is part of a beautiful mosaic

Respect.