Who was the greatest general of all time?

[Jason Voorhees]

Imo it's between these two

 

[Jason Voorhees]

@iloveboobs

 

[iloveboobs]

hitler

 

[Jason Voorhees]

hitler

No. And he wasn't a general. U probably mean manstein or guderian

 

[iloveboobs]

but really it was belisarius of byzantium

 

[Yliaster]

Are you asking who was better between just those 2 or in general ?

 

[iloveboobs]

No. And he wasn't a general. U probably mean manstein or guderian

he wasnt just a general, he lead the whole army after the battle of moscow

 

[Jason Voorhees]

Are you asking who was better between just those 2 or in general ?

In general

 

[Ghoulish]

Napoleon tbh. Relatively, france was much stronger than Germany in ww2. They took on every world power, including the British at their peak.

Genghis khan was a cunt and his generals were also as skilled as him if not more, he just takes all the credit.

 

[Ghoulish]

he wasnt just a general, he lead the whole army after the battle of moscow

The Germans were at their peak performance during the invasion of France.

 

[sportsmogger]

Its very clearly none of these two

Its Khalid Ibn Walid

 

[Lovecraftscat]

Ghengis Khan was the highest SMV in any human being, bro breedmaxxed more than any other human on this planet

 

[14vic]

Erwin rommel

 

[Ghoulish]

Its very clearly none of these two

Its Khalid Ibn Walid

Muslim?

 

[Ron.Belgrade]

General ratko mladić is underrated

 

[sportsmogger]

Muslim?

Yes, the General for Muhammad

Never lost a battle in his life

 

[iloveboobs]

The Germans were at their peak performance during the invasion of France.

germany got lucky

 

[Ghoulish]

Yes, the General for Muhammad

Never lost a battle in his life

I’m saying if YOU are

 

[CL8]

Imo it's between these two

View attachment 3211416View attachment 3211417

It's me

 

[Ghoulish]

germany got lucky

Germany was gonna destroy them either way, they just got lucky as well which lead to complete humiliation of the allies.

 

[sportsmogger]

I’m saying if YOU are

Im agnostic

I mean I used to adhere to Islam but recently ive been more nihilistic than ever

I can appreciate Religion though

 

[Jason Voorhees]

Napoleon tbh. Relatively, france was much stronger than Germany in ww2. They took on every world power, including the British at their peak.

Genghis khan was a cunt and his generals were also as skilled as him if not more, he just takes all the credit.

The duke of wellington still defeated them tho. Also the battle of trafalgar among other campaigns. Gengis khan was unstoppable but napoleon also deserves to be on there because he won many battles where he was heavily outnumbered.

 

[iloveboobs]

Yes, the General for Muhammad

Never lost a battle in his life

coulndt you say suvorov is the greatest? he never lost

 

[sportsmogger]

coulndt you say suvorov is the greatest? he never lost

Did he impact the world as much as Khalid did

 

[iloveboobs]

The duke of wellington still defeated them tho. Also a battle of trafalgar among other campaigns. Gengis khan wss unstoppable but napoleon also deserves to be on there because he won many battles where he was heavily outnumbered.

temujin was more of an administrative genius than general

 

[Ghoulish]

The duke of wellington still defeated them tho. Also a battle of trafalgar among other campaigns. Gengis khan wss unstoppable but napoleon also deserves to be on there because he won many battles where he was heavily outnumbered.

Battle of trafalgar was mainly from British naval superiority from beforehand. Duke of wellington was also a genius and used a tactic I’m pretty sure was never used before by turning the ships.

 

[iloveboobs]

Did he impact the world as much as Khalid did

does impact equal greatness

 

[Ghoulish]

Did he impact the world as much as Khalid did

Khalid is one of the reasons Islam still exists by an atheistic perspective. He’s the most impactful out of them all

 

[piec]

what about hannibal or these other niggers

 

[sportsmogger]

does impact equal greatness

Definitely, why else do we still talk about Napoleon even though he lost

Why dont people talk about the man who defeated Napoleon??

 

[Jason Voorhees]

Germany was gonna destroy them either way, they just got lucky as well which lead to complete humiliation of the allies.

Luck had a major role too. France had the magginot line and fully prepared. The French never expected a blitzkrieg from the ardnese forest. Had germany fought in thr traditional way like in WW1. Germans would have been pushed back within a few months. .

 

[sportsmogger]

what about hannibal or these other niggers

Hannibal got owned by Scipio

 

[iloveboobs]

Definitely, why else do we still talk about Napoleon even though he lost

Why dont people talk about the man who defeated Napoleon??

if we go by influence its scipio africanus or alexander

 

[PrinceLuenLeoncur]

Luck had a major role too. France had the magginot line and fully prepared. The French never expected a blitzkrieg from the ardnese forest. Had germany fought in thr traditional way like in WW1. Germans would have been pushed back within a few months. .

Napoleon

According to the stats he has the greatest KD it’s crazy but true.

 

[piec]

Hannibal got owned by Scipio

idk maybe i didnt get to the end of his history

in a fair fight he would probably fuck him up since carthage ignored him while romans kept shitting out soldiers

 

[Ghoulish]

Luck had a major role too. France had the magginot line and fully prepared. The French never expected a blitzkrieg from the ardnese forest. Had germany fought in thr traditional way like in WW1. Germans would have been pushed back within a few months. .

That’s because they created a tactic, not because of luck. Like saying napoleon beat the coalition by luck (more reasonable)

 

[Ghoulish]

Ghengis Khan was the highest SMV in any human being, bro breedmaxxed more than any other human on this planet

Rapemaxxed*

 

[PrinceLuenLeoncur]

Its very clearly none of these two

Its Khalid Ibn Walid

He’s too 5 for sure but not beating these GOATs

 

[MaghrebGator]

Generals who had strong and gigantic armies and who faced weaker ones should be just out of the conversation

 

[Ghoulish]

Didn’t know there were this many history neeks in .org lmao

 

[klip11]

Imo it's between these two

View attachment 3211416View attachment 3211417

Haitian cannibal general

 

[Ghoulish]

Generals who had strong and gigantic armies and who faced weaker ones should be just out of the conversation

Pretty sure no one said so far applies to that. Apart from the Germans.

 

[iloveboobs]

Generals who had strong and gigantic armies and who faced weaker ones should be just out of the conversation

then its belisarius

 

[Lovecraftscat]

Rapemaxxed*

Pretty much any marriage before like 100 years was rape

 

[gigell]

Stephen the Great

 

[iloveboobs]

Stephen the Great

cope

 

[lemonnz]

Alexander the Great

 

[gigell]

cope

He won 46 out of 48 battles and he mogs

 

[MaghrebGator]

Pretty sure no one said so far applies to that. Apart from the Germans.

WW2 Germany and whoever directed the Blitz onto France while invading the eastern front should be up there

Its probably the most iconic quick invasion. Of course we are biased because its in the beggining of the TV era and so on, but it still sounds crazy. They totally destroyed tactically France and their reputation at that time in a matter of weeks, which was of the greatest and most solid army in Europe at the time, with weaker equipment in regards to tanks and vehicles and so on from what i've heard.

 

[Yliaster]

High IQ discussion damn lol

Upvoting and reading through all of your comments