Would it be ethically correct to punish someone who murdered people but can’t remember

[presible]

Say he suffered amnesia and now lives as a kind person would it still be correct to punish him even if no knowledge of it, most people would ofc say yes but then atp what is the punishment supposed to accomplish.

 

[Resonant]

Say he suffered amnesia and now lives as a kind person would it still be correct to punish him even if no knowledge of it, most people would ofc say yes but then atp what is the punishment supposed to accomplish.

Lives can't be recalled like how you do with memories

 

[Ahmed88]

Ethically, you need a "guily mind", to be considered punishable

So technically, no

 

[IndecentEyes]

@Amnesia

Say he suffered amnesia

 

[muhajudin21]

yes because its still him and as a society punishment must be upheld

 

[itsoverforyoubro]

Losing memory wouldn’t change what kind of person you are