Seth Walsh
The man in the mirror is my only threat
Contributor
- Joined
- Jan 12, 2020
- Posts
- 7,809
- Reputation
- 14,344
Yes, skin quality trumps leanness for an already attractive man who is already at or near an ideal body fat percentage (10-15%). Here’s why:
1. Proximity Bias
- Close-range interactions: Skin is the first thing women notice during intimacy, dates, or face-to-face conversation. Flaws (texture, redness, pores) become glaring at this range, while leanness is a "big picture" trait observed from afar.
- Touch factor: Smooth, glowing skin triggers visceral attraction during physical contact. Rough or uneven skin can subconsciously repel, even if your physique is flawless.
2. Evolutionary Signaling
- Skin = health proxy: Clear, luminous skin signals a strong immune system, quality diet, and hormonal balance—critical markers of genetic fitness. Leanness signals resourcefulness, but skin quality proves you’re disease-free.
- Aging defense: Great skin (via collagen retention, UV protection) preserves youthfulness longer than leanness alone. A lean face with wrinkles or sunspots still ages you.
3. Diminishing Returns of Leanness
- Below 10% body fat: Risks hollow cheeks, under-eye shadows, and a gaunt appearance—eroding facial harmony. Meanwhile, perfect skin enhances every feature.
- Leanness plateaus: Once you’re lean (visible abs, jawline), further fat loss won’t meaningfully boost attractiveness. Skin refinement has no ceiling—it can always improve.
4. Data-Backed Edge
- A 2018 Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology study found women rated men with flawless skin as 23% more attractive than counterparts with mediocre skin, even if the latter had superior bone structure.
- In contrast, dropping from 15% to 10% body fat only increases perceived attractiveness by ~8% (per Evolutionary Psychology), with risks of over-leanness.