Approaches to Moderating Racist Content

Which approach is preferable?

  • Option 1

    Votes: 23 65.7%
  • Option 2

    Votes: 12 34.3%

  • Total voters
    35
  • Poll closed .
Alexanderr

Alexanderr

Admin
Joined
Mar 5, 2019
Posts
22,104
Reputation
45,223
I've already mentioned it in the mod chat and discussed it plenty, so I'll be requesting user input this time.

Our primary intent is to reduce the overall presence of racist content on the forum & prevent it from dominating our discussions while maintaining free speech, but I had some qualms with the current policy.

With this goal in mind, let's consider two different approaches.

1. The first option is to do away with the current race-baiting rule, due to concerns about its ambiguity and inconsistent application. (E.g. deciding whether a post is just a racist joke or crosses into race-baiting territory).
Instead, deleting or warning those who spam racist content, while clearly defining what constitutes spamming versus regular posting.
It would be easier to identify whether a post is racist than to discern where a racist joke crosses into race-baiting territory, increasing consistency.

2. The second option is to maintain the race-baiting rule following its recent clarification. This would mean continuing with the current guidelines, with the added clarity provided.

While I can't promise the outcome, it's useful to understand user perspective on the matter.
 
  • +1
  • JFL
  • Ugh..
Reactions: NumbThePain, Deleted member 48681, Lmao and 6 others
I've already mentioned it in the mod chat and discussed it plenty, so I'll be requesting user input this time.

Our primary intent is to reduce the overall presence of racist content on the forum & prevent it from dominating our discussions while maintaining free speech, but I had some qualms with the current policy.

With this goal in mind, let's consider two different approaches.

1. The first option is to do away with the current race-baiting rule, due to concerns about its ambiguity and inconsistent application. (E.g. deciding whether a post is just a racist joke or crosses into race-baiting territory).
Instead, deleting or warning those who spam any form of racist content, while clearly defining what constitutes spamming versus regular posting.
It would be easier to identify whether a post is racist than to discern where a racist joke crosses into race-baiting territory, increasing consistency.

2. The second option is to maintain the race-baiting rule following its recent clarification. This would mean continuing with the current guidelines, with the added clarity provided.

While I can't promise the outcome, it's useful to understand user perspective on the matter.
@Ai Impact you're next
 
  • JFL
  • +1
Reactions: 5'7 zoomer, Deleted member 43058, Deleted member 33711 and 2 others
free @CurryAscender
 
  • JFL
Reactions: Deleted member 48681
free @CurryAscender
He'd be one of those users that would get banned regardless of which option is chosen here.
 
  • JFL
Reactions: PickleTheSlayer, 5'7 zoomer, Deleted member 48681 and 15 others
  • JFL
  • Ugh..
Reactions: Deleted member 48681 and BitchBoy
Can I still say nigger?
 
  • JFL
  • +1
Reactions: 5'7 zoomer, TheMaxxer333, TechnoBoss and 3 others
  • +1
  • JFL
Reactions: Deleted member 48681, Lmao, TechnoBoss and 2 others
  • JFL
  • +1
Reactions: bedes, 5'7 zoomer, TheMaxxer333 and 9 others
Yes, we're not so much moderating what type of racism here, as opposed to those who spam it.
Summer Driving GIF

Monkey monkey monkey monkey!!!!! Monkeeyu aa FK NIGGER I GONNA LYNCH YOU
 
  • JFL
Reactions: sportsmogger, wsada and Fiqh
Its all gay, leave it as it was
 
  • +1
Reactions: dantemaxxing
  • JFL
  • +1
  • Love it
Reactions: bedes, dantemaxxing, Deleted member 48681 and 5 others
tf?

bbc threads are the lifeblood of this forum
 
  • +1
  • JFL
Reactions: Deleted member 43058 and Deleted member 47332
I hadn't even seen this yet...

 
Ban people who spam the BBC shit every day please, it's unbelievably annoying. Thanks
 
  • +1
Reactions: dantemaxxing, Lmao and Fiqh
Yeah it's mainly low effort spam that fucks everything up. Let my nigga @moggathon make an anti nigger thread or 2
 
  • JFL
  • +1
  • Love it
Reactions: SteveRogers, Deleted member 41390 and kebab
it just has to be congruent with reality. race bait about nig iq, crime, etc is fine. but constant bbc posting nigs just copy and paste memes made by white people and replace the white subject with blacks is junk content.
 
  • JFL
Reactions: DR. NICKGA and Deleted member 48681
The constant bbc posting with like 10 users actually being black is hilarious
 
  • JFL
Reactions: kebab
I've already mentioned it in the mod chat and discussed it plenty, so I'll be requesting user input this time.

Our primary intent is to reduce the overall presence of racist content on the forum & prevent it from dominating our discussions while maintaining free speech, but I had some qualms with the current policy.

With this goal in mind, let's consider two different approaches.

1. The first option is to do away with the current race-baiting rule, due to concerns about its ambiguity and inconsistent application. (E.g. deciding whether a post is just a racist joke or crosses into race-baiting territory).
Instead, deleting or warning those who spam racist content, while clearly defining what constitutes spamming versus regular posting.
It would be easier to identify whether a post is racist than to discern where a racist joke crosses into race-baiting territory, increasing consistency.

2. The second option is to maintain the race-baiting rule following its recent clarification. This would mean continuing with the current guidelines, with the added clarity provided.

While I can't promise the outcome, it's useful to understand user perspective on the matter.
Racist news content should be allowed but I think the porn posting should be limited. It’s just too much controversy,makes no sense and backed by zero facts. My post for example was just pure racism and spreading awareness of violence on an innocent animal. I wasn’t trying to bait a reaction off of the boons. The mods hate me and are trying to shut down my operation.
 
Yeah it's mainly low effort spam that fucks everything up. Let my nigga @moggathon make an anti nigger thread or 2
Or 3
 
  • +1
Reactions: Deleted member 21345

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top