Free Will? Poll

[Patriot]

What is your stance buddy boyos?

 

[Deleted member 4645]

Why do I keep seeing this debate everywhere JFL

 

[JMax]

Free will only exists for Chad.

 

[Patriot]

Why do I keep seeing this debate everywhere JFL

Where did you see it before?

 

[Deleted member 4645]

Where did you see it before?

YouTube, I get a shit ton of recommendation about philosophical topics and this is the most common one

 

[Deleted member 3832]

Nigga you need to learn how to speak English first. Then talk about free will.

 

[Deleted member 4310]

I believe in genetic determinism. Your iq and your looks will have a huge impact on your mannerisms and life outcome.

 

[Deleted member 4562]

Anyone who says they are certain free will does not exist has not read any primary literature on the topic or has only read Sam Harris.

If it exists, there are degrees of free will, Chad with high IQ, good family and education has more free will than the inner city black kid who lived in substandard housing and ate lead paint, and that black kid is going to have more free will than the 8 year old African who got drafted into a child army in the Congo.

 

[Patriot]

Nigga you need to learn how to speak English first. Then talk about free will.

irrelevant

 

[SHARK]

Anyone who says they are certain free will does not exist has not read any primary literature on the topic or has only read Sam Harris.

Yea that's who I learned the "there's no free will" argument from for the first time. I just said idk in the poll because I feel like the core of what free will is is debatable.

 

[Deleted member 4562]

Yea that's who I learned the "there's no free will" argument from for the first time. I just said idk in the poll because I feel like the core of what free will is is debatable.

A topic that spans 2000 years and has received so much contemporary discussion in both philosophy and neuroscience and that hack thinks he can prove it doesn't exist in a 96 page book.

It's so sad that that idiot is so many people's first introduction to the topic.

 

[Alt Number 3]

A topic that spans 2000 years and has received so much contemporary discussion in both philosophy and neuroscience and that hack thinks he can prove it doesn't exist in a 96 page book.

It's so sad that that idiot is so many people's first introduction to the topic.

How can I tag your username

 

[Deleted member 2205]

Free will exists.
Life is just biology and chemistry. You are what you are.

 

[Deleted member 1100]

There's an article that says we take action a couple miliseconds before even thinking about it.

Maybe it's all chemical, and the action happens before and the thinking come later as a justificative, but again, something would have to happen before the chemical reaction to cause the action

 

[Chadelite]

What is your stance buddy boyos?

Yep if you want to jump off cliff you can do it

We all have free will odgaf about genetics

 

[Deleted member 3043]

relative free will exist and is compatible.
you need to read a bit on that matter.

 

[Deleted member 4562]

Also since I just came back to this thread,

Compatibilism is cope and there is a reason there has been a push towards incompatibilist discussions in the last couple of decades.

 

[Deleted member 4310]

I must have free will because I dn rd by choice

 

[Deleted member 2846]

No. Free will doesn’t exist.

 

[Patriot]

Yep if you want to jump off cliff you can do it

We all have free will odgaf about genetics

how do you know this?

 

[Deleted member 2100]

I think although Free Will does not exist, it's up to you to make the choices.

Meaning even if Free Will does not exist that is not how it is presented to you. As an individual you feel there are options to change/improve your life, and there are. You are to make your own decisions.

On a large scale although this is scientifically and philosophically valid, in the real world you will have choices to make. There is a different substance grounded in reality barred from the abstractness of Free Will vs. Determinism.

 

[Deleted member 2846]

@

Also since I just came back to this thread,

Compatibilism is cope and there is a reason there has been a push towards incompatibilist discussions in the last couple of decades.

There is no free will

Free will does not exist. If you look at a football player, you think to yourself, “he is a footballer because he is big and tall” not “he is big tall because he is a football player.” This is due to the labels we put on things. We label things to people and those people form or have already...

looksmax.org

 

[Deleted member 3043]

Also since I just came back to this thread,

Compatibilism is cope and there is a reason there has been a push towards incompatibilist discussions in the last couple of decades.

there is a reason for your ignorance also.

@

There is no free will

Free will does not exist. If you look at a football player, you think to yourself, “he is a footballer because he is big and tall” not “he is big tall because he is a football player.” This is due to the labels we put on things. We label things to people and those people form or have already...

looksmax.org

cope
actually you admit some odd form of free will in your thread.

 

[Deleted member 4562]

@

There is no free will

Free will does not exist. If you look at a football player, you think to yourself, “he is a footballer because he is big and tall” not “he is big tall because he is a football player.” This is due to the labels we put on things. We label things to people and those people form or have already...

looksmax.org

Free will doesn't mean you can become anything you want or do whatever you want, it means you at least have more than one possibility. Which you even state at the end of your post.