D
Deleted member 43557
Luminary
- Joined
- Sep 6, 2023
- Posts
- 9,043
- Reputation
- 8,492
- OP
- #51
Firstly akhi I am pragmatic I don't take hadeeths too seriously I follow imam Malik,the people of medinah and am a sufi first before a sunni and even shaykh albani said even bukhari has mistakesImam Ali (AS) said at the time of the attack that if Rasulullah ﷺ had not ordered me to be patient (in order to not cause a civil war as soon as the Prophet ﷺ died) I would have killed you.
The attack on the house of Fatima Zahra (SA) has been admitted by leading Sunni leaders including Abu Bakr himself who said when he was about to die that I wish that I did not attack the house of Fatima even if it was a centre of war against me.
This is narrated by Sunni scholars like:
1. Al-Tabarani in al-Mo'jam al-Kabeer ,
2. al-Dhahabi in Meesan al-E'tidaal,
3. Ibn Qutaiba and quoted by Ibn A'bd Rabbih in his book al-E'qd al-Fareed.
4. al-Mas'oodi in amorous al-Dhahab.
5. Ibn Asaakir in Tareekh Dimishq.
6. al-Haithami in Majma' al-Zawaa'id.
7. al-Soyouti in Musnad Fatimah
8. al-Muttaqi al-Hindi in Kanz al-Ummaal.
Beside this, we have hundreds of Sunni books who narrated about the attack and fire to burn the house or door of Fatima (SA):
1. Tareekh al-Tabari , V.2, P. 443.
2. Mussannaf Abi Shaibah, V. 8, P. 572.
3. al-E'qd al-Fareed , V.2, P. 73.
4. Ibn Abd al-Barr in al-Estee'aab, V. 1, P. 298.
5. al-Waafi bil Wafayaat by al-Safari, V.2, P.227.
6. Kanzul Ummah , V.5, P.651.
7. Abul-Fidaa' in al-Mukhtasar Fi aakhbaar al- Bashar, V.1, P.107.
8. Ibn Taymiyyah (the staunch enemy of Ahlul Bayt) in his book Minhajul Sunnah, V.8, P. 291.
9.Ibn Hajar al-A'sqalani in Lisaan al-Mizan, V.1, P.111.
10. al-Dhahbi in Milan al-E'tidaal, V.1, P. 139 and in Siyar A'laam al-Nubalaa', V. 15, P. 578.
11. Al-Tabarani in al-Mo'jam al-Kabeer , V.1, P. 17.
12, Al-Haithami on Mo'jam al-Zawaa'id, V.2, P. 353.
Difference is we accept this but shias have very bad corrupted hadiths but think they came from ahlu bayt when they came from someone sayyidna Jafar al Sadiq radiallahu taala anhu said was a zindiq
Sayyidna Muhammed salamallah alihi had ghayrah more than any other creation and would never tell Ali to be patient when it's the duty of a Muslim let alone a fearless masoom to fight til the death to protect his women's folk honor