Seth Walsh
Iconoclast
Contributor
- Joined
- Jan 12, 2020
- Posts
- 11,003
- Reputation
- 22,481
The entire class system makes more sense once you understand this.
People think class = how much money you have.
Wrong variable.
Class is how often life can force you to transact at a shit price.
A normal person loses his job with 3 months of runway.
He cannot wait 12 months for the perfect role.
He starts hitting Easy Apply.
Takes the £55k offer instead of holding out for £90k.
Moves somewhere cheaper.
Stops investing.
Possibly sells investments.
Signs another rental because buying is now impossible.
Nothing dramatic happened.
But he just crystallised five separate losses because he had no ability to wait.
That is downward mobility in practice.
Now give the exact same shock to someone whose family has £5m.
He loses his job.
Nothing happens.
Mortgage/rent isn't existential.
Parents can bridge him.
He can reject shit offers.
He can spend six months getting into the correct firm.
He can move to London/New York without caring about the deposit.
His investments remain untouched.
He may actually increase his position during the downturn.
Same recession.
One person gets liquidated by it.
The other gets inventory.
This is the part people miss.
The lower classes are structurally SHORT VOLATILITY.
They need:
salary to arrive on time
rent not to increase
car not to break
relationship not to collapse
health not to deteriorate
employer not to restructure
Too many things must remain normal.
The wealthy are effectively LONG VOLATILITY.
Volatility creates:
cheap property
distressed businesses
better labour availability
career openings
forced sellers
mispriced assets
Their downside is capped by the family balance sheet while the upside remains open.
That asymmetry compounds for decades.
This is also why salary is such a hilariously bad class metric.
A £150k employee with a £5k monthly burn, two children, a mortgage and £40k cash can be far more fragile than a £60k guy sitting inside a £3m family balance sheet.
The first guy looks richer every month.
The second guy can survive three bad years without changing strategy.
Guess who has more negotiating power.
Real class privilege is not getting everything handed to you.
It is never having to press the red button.
Never having to sell the house now.
Never having to take the job now.
Never having to borrow now.
Never having to move now.
Never having to cash out now.
Never having to marry now.
Never having to tolerate someone now.
You can wait until the price comes to you.
People think class = how much money you have.
Wrong variable.
Class is how often life can force you to transact at a shit price.
A normal person loses his job with 3 months of runway.
He cannot wait 12 months for the perfect role.
He starts hitting Easy Apply.
Takes the £55k offer instead of holding out for £90k.
Moves somewhere cheaper.
Stops investing.
Possibly sells investments.
Signs another rental because buying is now impossible.
Nothing dramatic happened.
But he just crystallised five separate losses because he had no ability to wait.
That is downward mobility in practice.
Now give the exact same shock to someone whose family has £5m.
He loses his job.
Nothing happens.
Mortgage/rent isn't existential.
Parents can bridge him.
He can reject shit offers.
He can spend six months getting into the correct firm.
He can move to London/New York without caring about the deposit.
His investments remain untouched.
He may actually increase his position during the downturn.
Same recession.
One person gets liquidated by it.
The other gets inventory.
This is the part people miss.
The lower classes are structurally SHORT VOLATILITY.
They need:
salary to arrive on time
rent not to increase
car not to break
relationship not to collapse
health not to deteriorate
employer not to restructure
Too many things must remain normal.
The wealthy are effectively LONG VOLATILITY.
Volatility creates:
cheap property
distressed businesses
better labour availability
career openings
forced sellers
mispriced assets
Their downside is capped by the family balance sheet while the upside remains open.
That asymmetry compounds for decades.
This is also why salary is such a hilariously bad class metric.
A £150k employee with a £5k monthly burn, two children, a mortgage and £40k cash can be far more fragile than a £60k guy sitting inside a £3m family balance sheet.
The first guy looks richer every month.
The second guy can survive three bad years without changing strategy.
Guess who has more negotiating power.
Real class privilege is not getting everything handed to you.
It is never having to press the red button.
Never having to sell the house now.
Never having to take the job now.
Never having to borrow now.
Never having to move now.
Never having to cash out now.
Never having to marry now.
Never having to tolerate someone now.
You can wait until the price comes to you.
THE SOCIAL CLASS PILL:
The poor own less.
The middle class owns enough to become terrified of losing it.
The rich own enough that they are rarely forced to crystallise losses.
Class is the distance between you and forced liquidation.
And almost every institution in society becomes more generous to you the less urgently you need it.
The poor own less.
The middle class owns enough to become terrified of losing it.
The rich own enough that they are rarely forced to crystallise losses.
Class is the distance between you and forced liquidation.
And almost every institution in society becomes more generous to you the less urgently you need it.
