Who would win in a fight? Grizzly bear vs man with giant sword?

[Jason Voorhees]

Title. Who would win in a fight to death. A male grizzly bear. 10 foot in length, 1000 lbs with insane strength and giant paws

Vs


A skilled swordman with a giant great sword say the Zweihänder. Because a short sword can't maintain distance and would useless against a bear.

 

[Deleted member 233411]

Title. Who would win in a fight to death. 10 foot in length, 1000 lbs with legendary strength

View attachment 4163974View attachment 4163975View attachment 4163976


Vs


A skilled swordman with a giant great sword day the Zweihänder. Because a short sword can't maintain distance and would useless against a bear.

View attachment 4163979View attachment 4163980View attachment 4163981

Guts

 

[Jason Voorhees]

@Debetro @pope @registerfasterusing

 

[A_H0T_Wombat]

Unless you can keep your distance once it gets close it's over

 

[Jason Voorhees]

Unless you can keep your distance once it gets close it's over

Vote

 

[Jason Voorhees]

@BigBallsLarry @slaters @htautist

 

[Deleted member 153838]

the bear wins, that sword isnt doing anything unless someone like Guts is using it

 

[BigBallsLarry]

you said a skilled swordsman, realistically a high iq person would know how to keep a bear away with a long and pointy sword.

eventually there'll come an opportunity for you to just do a quick jab and Inpale it.

 

[Jason Voorhees]

the bear wins, that sword isnt doing anything unless someone like Guts is using it

 

[Htautistgymmaxx]

@BigBallsLarry @slaters @htautist

How tall and heavy is the sword user

 

[Mitakaa1341]

Drew McInyire could do it. I don't know if anyone else can.

 

[Deleted member 153838]

View attachment 4163993

maybe you could use a sword against a wolf

 

[Jason Voorhees]

How tall and heavy is the sword user

Would that really matter against a bear that is 5x the size anyway.

 

[registerfasterusing]

Title. Who would win in a fight to death. A male grizzly bear. 10 foot in length, 1000 lbs with insane strength and giant paws

View attachment 4163974View attachment 4163975View attachment 4163976


Vs


A skilled swordman with a giant great sword say the Zweihänder. Because a short sword can't maintain distance and would useless against a bear.

View attachment 4163979View attachment 4163980View attachment 4163981

Bear for sure

 

[Htautistgymmaxx]

Would that really matter against a bear that is 5x the size anyway.

Would affect how easily they can swing a giant sword and also their durability

 

[Deleted member 223853]

peak thread

 

[registerfasterusing]

Would affect how easily they can swing a giant sword and also their durability

Maybe if the nigga is like 8ft tall, but otherwise i doubt itl make a difference

 

[Jason Voorhees]

Bear for sure

I think bear too. I there's not a lot you can physically do against something that massive in size compared to you. Best you can do is somehow dodge it and land a hit on its face or some vital organs. If you miss it's GG

 

[Jason Voorhees]

@VohnnyBoy @hopecel

 

[Swarthy Knight]

This should've been the real debate instead of the 100 men normie bullshit

 

[VohnnyBoy]

if a blade is sharp enough, man

 

[Jason Voorhees]

if a blade is sharp enough, man

Doubt it.

 

[Eggbert]

swordsman no diff

 

[Jason Voorhees]

Bear for sure

Damn swordsman is winning

 

[registerfasterusing]

Damn swordsman is winning

Im surprised
I think ppl are overestimating our strength compared to nature here

 

[FutureSlayer]

bear, a man would have problems waving a sword that big and inflicting damage before the bear attacks

 

[registerfasterusing]

Im surprised
I think ppl are overestimating our strength compared to nature here

Although ig thats natural for humans to do

 

[Jason Voorhees]

bear, a man would have problems waving a sword that big and inflicting damage before the bear attacks

It can used to poke too

 

[FutureSlayer]

It can used to poke too

How would you poke with a sword that big? You can't keep it horizontal

 

[Andremln]

Bear obviously jfl

 

[Gargantuan]

The physical disparity is insurmountable through skill alone. This wouldn't be an issue if it were a slow and cumbersome animal since the man could simply outrun it, tire it out and then deliver a fatal blow (man wins easily in this scenario, same reason why Goatis would unironically beat Eddie Hall in a fight), but bears are literally made for endurance and can outrun any man, so that doesn't apply here.

The margin of error is asymmetric. The man gets one mistake before incapacitation, whilst the bear can absorb multiple deep wounds and stay in the fight, since penetrating its thick hide to reach vital organs is no easy feat.
The weapon's reach advantage is most likely negated by the bear's own dimensions as well.
Even when landing a perfect vital strike, the bear wouldn't die instantly and could most likely still find a way to deliver lethal trauma with a bite force and paw swipes that can crush bones.

 

[Jason Voorhees]

How would you poke with a sword that big? You can't keep it horizontal

Zweihänder have large length but still quite light wnd agile too. It's common mid conception than greatswords are too big

 

[FutureSlayer]

Zweihänder have large length but still quite light wnd agile too. It's common mid conception than greatswords are too big

Yes, I see but how would you poke with it? It's not like you can push real force with that by keeping it horizontal

 

[Jason Voorhees]

Yes, I see but how would you poke with it? It's not like you can push real force with that by keeping it horizontal

Maybe the bear will impale itself under its own weight?

 

[Jason Voorhees]

The physical disparity is insurmountable through skill alone. This wouldn't be an issue if it were a slow and cumbersome animal since the man could simply outrun it, tire it out and then deliver a fatal blow (man wins easily in this scenario, same reason why Goatis would unironically beat Eddie Hall in a fight), but bears are literally made for endurance and can outrun any man, so that doesn't apply here.

The margin of error is asymmetric. The man gets one mistake before incapacitation, whilst the bear can absorb multiple deep wounds and stay in the fight, since penetrating its thick hide to reach vital organs is no easy feat.
The weapon's reach advantage is most likely negated by the bear's own dimensions as well.
Even when landing a perfect vital strike, the bear wouldn't die instantly and could most likely still find a way to deliver lethal trauma with a bite force and paw swipes that can crush bones.

Couldn't have said it better

 

[Yliaster]

Nerves of Steel and the Sharpness of the Sword will be the most crucial factors here to the point where you only
get one swipe and must make it count or else the Bear will literally end you in a matter of seconds

 

[Yliaster]

An anxious person wielding a sword would actually harm both himself and the Bear.

This is basically a battle of Nerves

 

[HtnGymcel]

Bear vs Guts

 

[Ältai.Anabolic]

Bear skull is literally designed to be almost impenetrable

 

[hopecel]

Bear for sure

How tall and heavy is the sword user

Bear skull is literally designed to be almost impenetrable

this robust Herzegovinian killed a bear merely with an axe @Debetro

 

[Sektor]

Title. Who would win in a fight to death. A male grizzly bear. 10 foot in length, 1000 lbs with insane strength and giant paws

View attachment 4163974View attachment 4163975View attachment 4163976


Vs


A skilled swordman with a giant great sword say the Zweihänder. Because a short sword can't maintain distance and would useless against a bear.

View attachment 4163979View attachment 4163980View attachment 4163981

Giant sword u have such a high chance winning then a fucking bear

 

[Uehdbwidbfngj]

Title. Who would win in a fight to death. A male grizzly bear. 10 foot in length, 1000 lbs with insane strength and giant paws

View attachment 4163974View attachment 4163975View attachment 4163976


Vs


A skilled swordman with a giant great sword say the Zweihänder. Because a short sword can't maintain distance and would useless against a bear.

View attachment 4163979View attachment 4163980View attachment 4163981

Man easily

 

[LosPollosTV]

I think bears are more pussu then u guys think, animals in general. Like one swing from the sword it will probably back off

If a bear charges straight at me at 25mph
As long as I’m stone cold it won’t even realize the sword I’m holding towards its chest is lethal, no?

 

[LampPostPrime]

The physical disparity is insurmountable through skill alone. This wouldn't be an issue if it were a slow and cumbersome animal since the man could simply outrun it, tire it out and then deliver a fatal blow (man wins easily in this scenario, same reason why Goatis would unironically beat Eddie Hall in a fight), but bears are literally made for endurance and can outrun any man, so that doesn't apply here.

The margin of error is asymmetric. The man gets one mistake before incapacitation, whilst the bear can absorb multiple deep wounds and stay in the fight, since penetrating its thick hide to reach vital organs is no easy feat.
The weapon's reach advantage is most likely negated by the bear's own dimensions as well.
Even when landing a perfect vital strike, the bear wouldn't die instantly and could most likely still find a way to deliver lethal trauma with a bite force and paw swipes that can crush bones.

Thanks chatgpt