Why do Christians accuse others of paedophilia when marry got pregnant at 12 years old

[LefortCandidate]

Genuine question brehs

 

[Theapeking]

No evidence

 

[coastal]

she didnt, there's zero evidence for this claim. it's just muslim made bs

 

[LefortCandidate]

No evidence

they say 12-14

 

[Hurly saint]

Genuine question brehs

U actually make decent point

 

[Theapeking]

they say 12-14

Who says that

 

[BelgradeSlayer]

She wasn't 12 bro wtf, she was 14-16 and according to Christian beliefs wasn't impregnanted

 

[LefortCandidate]

Who says that

She wasn't 12 bro wtf, she was 14-16 and according to Christian beliefs wasn't impregnanted

she didnt, there's zero evidence for this claim. it's just muslim made bs

 

[LefortCandidate]

No evidence

she didnt, there's zero evidence for this claim. it's just muslim made bs

Who says that

She wasn't 12 bro wtf, she was 14-16 and according to Christian beliefs wasn't impregnanted

this scholar says 12-14 (time stamped)

 

[Lyndon]

View attachment 5032357

Thanks for proving his point.... bhai
"many scholars suggest 14-16, with some estimates reaching 18"

 

[LefortCandidate]

Thanks for proving his point.... bhai

the scholar consensus is 12-14

see the video above

 

[BelgradeSlayer]

"MANY SCHOLARS SUGGEST SHE WAS LIKELY 14-16"
There's only 2 sources :
-the Protoevangelium of James reported that she was 16 years old when she became pregnant with Jesus
-History of Joseph the Carpenter claimed she was 14 years old.

 

[coastal]

View attachment 5032357

correct, guesses and estimates. and according to Church tradition and writings of saints she was taken from the temple after puberty, so she was likely 15-18 or so, which a completely normal age to marry during 1st century.

also all the church fathers, saints and Jesus Christ Himself always said that sex with children is one of the worst sins and it's the official position of the Church to this day

 

[Lyndon]

the scholar consensus is 12-14

see the video above

Why are you retracting now from the ss you sent?
Aside from that, even If we would grant that she is 12, could you explain to us how is that pedophilia?

 

[coastal]

this scholar says 12-14 (time stamped)

thats a video of 2 manlets yapping about their guesses

as google told you, there is no evidence for this claim.

 

[fedecope]

becausw christianity is slop

 

[LefortCandidate]

correct, guesses and estimates. and according to Church tradition and writings of saints she was taken from the temple after puberty, so she was likely 15-18 or so, which a completely normal age to marry during 1st century.

also all the church fathers, saints and Jesus Christ Himself always said that sex with children is one of the worst sins and it's the official position of the Church to this day

wrong

she was 12-14

see this

 

[Lyndon]

thats a video of 2 manlets yapping about their guesses

as google told you, there is no evidence for this claim.

Still if we concede that she is 12
He is not gonna be able to answer how is that pedophilia JFL

 

[LefortCandidate]

thats a video of 2 manlets yapping about their guesses

as google told you, there is no evidence for this claim.

ah breh these are credible scholars in the christian cimmunity

 

[CollioureViews]

Genuine question brehs

If your title is sincere...?

I guess you're referring to how we trash muslims???

It's because there's a high likelihood that Mary, ignoring the virgin birth and lifelong virginity for a second, would have at least looked sexually dimorphic; if Joseph was aroused by her, that's not pedo.

Muhammad, on the other hand, went for a 9 y/o.

All the way.

I've never seen a dimorphic 9 y/o - they look indistinguishable from little boys...

Hence, pedo.

 

[Hess]

Even if she was pregnant at this age i dont rly see the issue considering it was a miracle birth that had nothing to do with sexual relations or anything

 

[Lyndon]

"MANY SCHOLARS SUGGEST SHE WAS LIKELY 14-16"
There's only 2 sources :
-the Protoevangelium of James reported that she was 16 years old when she became pregnant with Jesus
-History of Joseph the Carpenter claimed she was 14 years old.

And this is in fact true
But this guy is trynna cope with it

 

[coastal]

ah breh these are credible scholars in the christian cimmunity

correct, they're heretics and not credible by any means

 

[LefortCandidate]

If your title is sincere...?

I guess you're referring to how we trash muslims???

It's because there's a high likelihood that Mary, ignoring the virgin birth and lifelong virginity for a second, would have at least looked sexually dimorphic; if Joseph was aroused by her, that's not pedo.

Muhammad, on the other hand, went for a 9 y/o.

All the way.

I've never seen a dimorphic 9 y/o - they look indistinguishable from little boys...

Hence, pedo.

12 yo aren't dimorphic breh

 

[BelgradeSlayer]

@LefortCandidate Even if she was 12 : How is it pedophilia when she gave birth as a VIRGIN

 

[Lyndon]

Even if she was pregnant at this age i dont rly see the issue considering it was a miracle birth that had nothing to do with sexual relations or anything

Thats why I asked him, even if we concede that is 12 there is no way pedophilia is involved
She remained virgin her whole life and she was in fact sinless untouched
And Joseph didn't even move a single finger, he acted like a father figure for Jesus and the protector of Mary, nothing more

 

[InertiaBoy]

Thats not pedophilia
Pedophilia is when you like children and children cant get pregnant cuz theyre prepubescent

 

[Theapeking]

Thats why I asked him, even if we concede that is 12 there is no way pedophilia is involved
She remained virgin her whole life and she was in fact sinless untouched
And Joseph didn't even move a single finger, he acted like a father figure for Jesus and the protector of Mary, nothing more

Because she was forced to carry a baby . Thats The bad part

 

[LefortCandidate]

Thats why I asked him, even if we concede that is 12 there is no way pedophilia is involved
She remained virgin her whole life and she was in fact sinless untouched
And Joseph didn't even move a single finger, he acted like a father figure for Jesus and the protector of Mary, nothing more

@LefortCandidate Even if she was 12 : How is it pedophilia when she gave birth as a VIRGIN

12 yo cannot consent breh

 

[Ultimate Subhuman™]

No evidence she got pregnant at 12

ah breh these are credible scholars in the christian cimmunity

Never heard of either of them
The only legitimate voice in the Christian community is the church

 

[Hess]

Thats why I asked him, even if we concede that is 12 there is no way pedophilia is involved
She remained virgin her whole life and she was in fact sinless untouched
And Joseph didn't even move a single finger, he acted like a father figure for Jesus and the protector of Mary, nothing more

People throw around the word pedo far too loosely its like the 90s satanic panic at this point

 

[Lyndon]

If your title is sincere...?

I guess you're referring to how we trash muslims???

It's because there's a high likelihood that Mary, ignoring the virgin birth and lifelong virginity for a second, would have at least looked sexually dimorphic; if Joseph was aroused by her, that's not pedo.

Muhammad, on the other hand, went for a 9 y/o.

All the way.

I've never seen a dimorphic 9 y/o - they look indistinguishable from little boys...

Hence, pedo.

Trvthnuke.

 

[CollioureViews]

12 yo aren't dimorphic breh

Disagree, they can be...

That's a statement of fact.

Everyone here has seen with their own eyes.

Now, less likely to be dimorphic vs. 14?

Of course. No argument.

Plus.

Virgin birth. That's a big deal.

In fact, a lifelong virgin.

That's a hella big deal.

 

[LefortCandidate]

No evidence she got pregnant at 12

Never heard of either of them
The only legitimate voice in the Christian community is the church

correct, they're heretics and not credible by any means

tommy aquinas also set age of marriage at 12 brehs

is he heretic ?

 

[kerchmaniac]

pedo means pre-pubescent
pre pubescent cannot be pregnant use this monkey brain of u

 

[BelgradeSlayer]

12 yo cannot consent breh

That has to be ragebait
You're fucking low IQ
SHE DIDN'T HAVE TO CONSENT BECAUSE NO ONE HAD SEXUAL INTERCOURSE WITH HER, AS SHE IS A VIRGIN. THAT'S IN HER NAME BRO

 

[InertiaBoy]

12 yo cannot consent breh

Proof? Nature made them able to get pregnant so why shouldnt they?

 

[LefortCandidate]

Disagree, they can be...

That's a statement of fact.

Everyone here has seen with their own eyes.

Now, less likely to be dimorphic vs. 14?

Of course. No argument.

Plus.

Virgin birth. That's a big deal.

In fact, a lifelong virgin.

That's a hella big deal.

ive never seen a dimorphic 12 yo breh

my issue is right here

you wouldn't grant the benefit of the doubt to other relegions

but for you

12 can be dimorphic

 

[CollioureViews]

tommy aquinas also set age of marriage at 12 brehs

is he heretic ?

There's also a big distinction I forgot.

Typing fast cause I wanna get food.

Muhammads life is sunnah; it's the perfect example for muslims to live.

No one in the Christian theology sets and example of fucking minors as perfection.

Big fookin difference...

Ciao, off for munch

 

[LefortCandidate]

That has to be ragebait
You're fucking low IQ
SHE DIDN'T HAVE TO CONSENT BECAUSE NO ONE HAD SEXUAL INTERCOURSE WITH HER, AS SHE IS A VIRGIN. THAT'S IN HER NAME BRO

if i drug you and inject you with my semen and you get pregnant

would this be okay BECAUSE I DIDN4T TECHNICHALLY PUT MY DICK INSIDE YOU ?

 

[Ultimate Subhuman™]

tommy aquinas also set age of marriage at 12 brehs

is he heretic ?

The only legitimate voice in the Christian community is the church

Thomas also didnt say that Mary had gone through the conception at twelve
He was just accepting of Child Marriage. But again im not a Thomist so Idc what he says

 

[Ahmed88]

Alot of their prophets married kids

Isaac
David
Their god himself had a thing for minors

 

[Lyndon]

Because she was forced to carry a baby . Thats The bad part

This guy talking about forcing when she clearly states that she wants to carry Jesus in Luke's Gospel
Aside from that, how is this 12 year old young girl making full and complete teological statements and traveling on her own to visit her cousin? for sure every 12 year old girl does that right?.

No evidence at all for what you are saying.

 

[LefortCandidate]

There's also a big distinction I forgot.

Typing fast cause I wanna get food.

Muhammads life is sunnah; it's the perfect example for muslims to live.

No one in the Christian theology sets and example of fucking minors as perfection.

Big fookin difference...

Ciao, off for munch

i am not muslim big bro

can you defend christianity without bringing others ?

 

[Ultimate Subhuman™]

if i drug you and inject you with my semen and you get pregnant

would this be okay BECAUSE I DIDN4T TECHNICHALLY PUT MY DICK INSIDE YOU ?

Not Analogous

 

[coastal]

tommy aquinas also set age of marriage at 12 brehs

is he heretic ?

he is not anathematized as a formal heretic but isnt considered a holy father or saint. and even if he was, i think it should be obvious that an opinion of one saint doesnt dictate what Christians believe.

what does is the ecumenical councils, which formally condemned child marriage and sex, for example councils of Elvira, Ancyra, Neocaesarea and Nicea 1

 

[Ultimate Subhuman™]

Alot of their prophets married kids

Isaac
David
Their god himself had a thing for minors

David & Issac arent Prophets nor seen as Prophets in the Christian view.
Plus, theres no evidence or either of their marriages being Consummated ( Sex ) Unlike Muhammed

 

[Gengar’s Ghost]

View attachment 5032357

Reddit is Muslim.

 

[Ahmed88]

David & Issac arent Prophets nor seen as Prophets in the Christian eyes.
Plus, theres no evidence or either of their marriages being Consummated ( Sex ) Unlike Muhammed

,,Saar muhammad have sex saar"

,,saar not prophets saar" ,,saar marrying children ok if no pregnant saar"

Not a single thing you said is true

 

[LefortCandidate]

Not Analogous

it is big bro

you can impregnates somebody indirectly like jesus did

he is not anathematized as a formal heretic but isnt considered a holy father or saint. and even if he was, i think it should be obvious that an opinion of one saint doesnt dictate what Christians believe.

what does is the ecumenical councils, which formally condemned child marriage and sex, for example councils of Elvira, Ancyra, Neocaesarea and Nicea 1

he is a father and reputable scholar of the catohlic church