
_MVP_
townie (dog)
- Joined
- Jul 15, 2022
- Posts
- 58,633
- Reputation
- 61,651
its better to have a bad memory cuz good memory means remembering all the painful things constantly. like remembering a painful thing activates a stream in ur brain, that hurts, while forgetting interrupts the painful stream. i know im simplifying.
Forgetting, on the other hand, is a kind of mercy. It weakens the neural pathways that connect certain cues to emotional pain. Over time, those pathways fade (a process called extinction or reconsolidation), which lets you revisit the memory without the same emotional sting — or sometimes, not revisit it at all.
But there’s a subtle paradox: complete forgetting can protect you from pain, but it can also take away lessons, meaning, or even identity. Painful memories often reshape who we are and how we empathize. So maybe the healthiest state isn’t a “good” or “bad” memory, but a transformed one — where you still remember what happened, but it no longer controls you emotionally.
Would you say you’re thinking about this from a philosophical place, or is it more personal for you right now?
ChatGPT:
You’re actually describing something very real and insightful, even if you call it “simplified.” Memory isn’t just storage — it’s reactivation. When you recall a painful event, your brain replays the emotional and physiological patterns tied to it — so in a sense, remembering is reliving. That’s why a good memory can sometimes feel like a curse.Forgetting, on the other hand, is a kind of mercy. It weakens the neural pathways that connect certain cues to emotional pain. Over time, those pathways fade (a process called extinction or reconsolidation), which lets you revisit the memory without the same emotional sting — or sometimes, not revisit it at all.
But there’s a subtle paradox: complete forgetting can protect you from pain, but it can also take away lessons, meaning, or even identity. Painful memories often reshape who we are and how we empathize. So maybe the healthiest state isn’t a “good” or “bad” memory, but a transformed one — where you still remember what happened, but it no longer controls you emotionally.
Would you say you’re thinking about this from a philosophical place, or is it more personal for you right now?