Jews are the only people who accept everyone and reject everyone simultaneously

[Deleted member 18522]

The Arab birth rate is going down a lot. The Israeli government tbh is probably going to deport most Palestinians it seemsc

They have already killed or injured nearly 4% of gaza's population

 

[Deleted member 55437]

They have already killed or injured nearly 4% of gaza's population

Hamas fault

 

[Deleted member 18522]

Hamas fault

You can't blame hamas for israel's barbaric response

 

[MaghrebGator]

Your argument is Palestinian nationalism didn't exist. I'm saying yes it did. Most Baathists saw their states as temporary western creations at the time too like Abdel Nasser. So in theory there really weren't any Egyptians, just "Arabs".

United Arab Republic - Wikipedia

en.m.wikipedia.org

Who cares if palestinian nationalism existed anyways? The concept of the nation state is something extremely recent in history, it's ridiculous to try to argue on that base and i have seen many zionists do it. I recommend the books of Wael Hallaq and also his interview in this arabic podcast channel (Put subtitles)

Also go to Blogging Theology where they review his book (The impossible state) in which he destroys this concept of the nation state being the everything that they try to sell us.

I can name you right now tens of states that didn't exist in the 1900s. The fact of the matter is that the native people of the land identified as palestinians, and there is this foreign invader who at first sought refugee but then with the help of the british colonizer decided to go all in with the invasion and ethnically cleanse many areas of the land, period.

Arguing of the existence of Palestine and the concept of the Palestinian nation is extremely easy. Tons of books and coins from the 1700s speaking of Palestine.

 

[Deleted member 55437]

You can't blame hamas for israel's barbaric response

FAFO

 

[Deleted member 55437]

Who cares if palestinian nationalism existed anyways? The concept of the nation state is something extremely recent in history, it's ridiculous to try to argue on that base and i have seen many zionists do it. I recommend the books of Wael Hallaq and also his interview in this arabic podcast channel (Put subtitles)

Also go to Blogging Theology where they review his book (The impossible state) in which he destroys this concept of the nation state being the everything that they try to sell us.

I can name you right now tens of states that didn't exist in the 1900s. The fact of the matter is that the native people of the land identified as palestinians, and there is this foreign invader who at first sought refugee but then with the help of the british colonizer decided to go all in with the invasion and ethnically cleanse many areas of the land, period.

Arguing of the existence of Palestine and the concept of the Palestinian nation is extremely easy. Tons of books and coins from the 1700s speaking of Palestine.

Just name one Palestinian before Arafat
Just one

 

[SecularIslamist]

Who cares if palestinian nationalism existed anyways? The concept of the nation state is something extremely recent in history, it's ridiculous to try to argue on that base and i have seen many zionists do it. I recommend the books of Wael Hallaq and also his interview in this arabic podcast channel (Put subtitles)

Also go to Blogging Theology where they review his book (The impossible state) in which he destroys this concept of the nation state being the everything that they try to sell us.

I can name you right now tens of states that didn't exist in the 1900s. The fact of the matter is that the native people of the land identified as palestinians, and there is this foreign invader who at first sought refugee but then with the help of the british colonizer decided to go all in with the invasion and ethnically cleanse many areas of the land, period.

Arguing of the existence of Palestine and the concept of the Palestinian nation is extremely easy. Tons of books and coins from the 1700s speaking of Palestine.

Thanks for the link. Bookmarked will come back to it later. I'm very anti nationalist tbh.

The impossible state was a great book by Hallaq. I got halfway through it and lost it to time and the Jews nerfed bookz.org.

 

[Squirtoutmabooty]