Mass immigration is good

[Skara]

My arguments completely make sense and can be observed in comparison the USA and Canada. Canada has experienced double the migration compared to population than the USA did. Where do u think living conditions for the middle/lower class are better. The US or canada?

idk never been there

well i've showed u previous patterns since the 20s, and 70s and now in the 2020s. This phenomenon occurs every 50 years where birth rates drop

completely different eras. Cannot be compared.

 

[Skara]

This is a literal short term fix. But because you don’t understand anything about the concepts of economics you’ll think this will actually work

Immigration will temporarily fill labor gaps, but it doesn’t fix the underlying demographic decline, especially when most immigrants eventually age too. Adding more people without proportional investment in infrastructure (housing, healthcare, schools) creates more pressure, not relief. immigration doesn’t significantly improve the old age dependency ratio long term unless birth rates rise too, which they don’t because the actual problem is not being fixed, which led to the citizens not having kids in the first place



It Literally does, you’re just to stubborn to admit your wrong. You claimed immigration is economically and demographically necessary, and then tried to pivot to labor shortages in sectors like agriculture as proof. But when the data shows immigrants make up less than 10% of Canadian farm operators, you suddenly say, “muh there are other reasons ” That’s again, called moving the goalposts.

Like high barriers to entry, lack of land access, capital requirements, and low margins, all of which immigrants don’t magically solve. So stop pretending “ muh immigration = solution ”

full blown retard

"Canadian farmers" - one single case and cuz of different reasons JFL.

 

[FiendFiend]

idk never been there

completely different eras. Cannot be compared.

If the phenomenon happens every 50 years and is a core part of demographics in the west, yeah maybe u should listen to it. As I said if ur still not convinced u should fix the birthrates via the methods i told u that have been proven to work. Its better to restrict some "rights" (as if killing a baby is a right anyway) to fix the birthrate than to mass import millions of indians , destroy social cohesion, destroy housing, destroy economic prospect, destroy entry level and blue collar wages.

And since ur not familiar with the english space since ti russki brat. Let me tell u. Life in canada is 1000x fucking worse than USA.

 

[TiktokUser]

and I didn't say that in the long term it's just as effective, migration is needed to compensate for current problems, not future ones, idiot. What a moron you are, kill your mother for giving birth to you lol

lol thanks for admitting mass immigration is not a real solution, and that it just delays the collapse without fixing the core issues

“Muh let’s keep importing people into a broken system, just to slow the bleeding ”

"Canadian farmers" - one single case and cuz of different reasons JFL.

Top 8 countries for agricultural in the world have less than 10% of farmers being immigrants

Russia, Canada, China

Absolute subhuman cope

 

[Skara]

If the phenomenon happens every 50 years and is a core part of demographics in the west, yeah maybe u should listen to it. As I said if ur still not convinced u should fix the birthrates via the methods i told u that have been proven to work. Its better to restrict some "rights" (as if killing a baby is a right anyway) to fix the birthrate than to mass import millions of indians , destroy social cohesion, destroy housing, destroy economic prospect, destroy entry level and blue collar wages.

And since ur not familiar with the english space since ti russki brat. Let me tell u. Life in canada is 1000x fucking worse than USA.

Abortion bans do not lead to a significant increase in the birth rate, but only increase the number of illegal and dangerous abortions. And also, limiting someone's rights (to their own body) is terrible. As for comparison with past eras, now there are completely different socio-economic conditions, different values and a different level of development of medicine. Therefore, it is incorrect to draw direct parallels. In addition, I believe that the negative consequences of immigration that you listed can be mitigated with the help of a competent integration policy, investment in infrastructure and regulation of the labor market

 

[FiendFiend]

Abortion bans do not lead to a significant increase in the birth rate, but only increase the number of illegal and dangerous abortions. And also, limiting someone's rights (to their own body) is terrible. As for comparison with past eras, now there are completely different socio-economic conditions, different values and a different level of development of medicine. Therefore, it is incorrect to draw direct parallels. In addition, I believe that the negative consequences of immigration that you listed can be mitigated with the help of a competent integration policy, investment in infrastructure and regulation of the labor market

jfl at these chatgpt responses I have sent u cases where this shit worked.

Stop using ai nigga and fuck off. Good night

 

[Skara]

lol thanks for admitting mass immigration is not a real solution, and that it just delays the collapse without fixing the core issues

I didn't admit anything, stop attributing to me things I didn't do retard. if the goal is to compensate (which was the priority for the country) then migration is the solution

“Muh let’s keep importing people into a broken system, just to slow the bleeding ”


Top 8 countries for agricultural in the world have less than 10% of farmers being immigrants

Russia, Canada, China

Absolute subhuman cope

What do you suggest instead?

jfl at these chatgpt responses I have sent u cases where this shit worked.

Stop using ai nigga and fuck off. Good night

even fucking ai IQ mogs you JFL.

 

[loyolaxavvierretard]

Immigration issue is greater so much so that it brutally pagemogs Kaligula's mass tagging and bumping yesterday

 

[Skara]

jfl at these chatgpt responses I have sent u cases where this shit worked.

Stop using ai nigga and fuck off. Good night

the fact that this is chatgpt doesn't change anything, you still can't answer shit

 

[TiktokUser]

I didn't admit anything, stop attributing to me things I didn't do retard. if the goal is to compensate (which was the priority for the country) then migration is the solution

Lmao you’re so retarded

Just because migration compensates in the short term doesn’t mean it solves underlying problems.

The fact that the top agricultural countrie Russia, Canada, and China have less than 10% of their farmers as immigrants shows that relying on a foreign workforce is not a sustainable long term solution. Why have an influx of immigrants if they’ll just be detrimental later on. Get this through your thick fucking pea brain skull

What do you suggest instead?

Idk can you not fucking read? Ive said this countless of times

Addressing the broken system with proper investment in housing, healthcare, and wages. Promote job creation, reform labor markets. Immigration isn’t a fix to any of these things you retard

Have you finally gotten it?

 

[TiktokUser]

jfl at these chatgpt responses I have sent u cases where this shit worked.

Stop using ai nigga and fuck off. Good night

LOL

that shit actually makes so much sense

No wonder that retard thinks thinks short term solutions that will be detrimental in long term, is good.

Over for him. He has to use an AI because he can’t even articulate what he’s trying to say.

 

[Askeladd93270]

It's a troll guys dont worry

 

[FiendFiend]

the fact that this is chatgpt doesn't change anything, you still can't answer shit

oh so u are using gpt. nvm bro gg. Im not talking to an ai. its like talking to a blank wall dawg. No matter how much times I explain it ur repeating urself, i think a human is intilligent enough to not repeat himself 1000 times so its pretty obvious ur just using ai. Why would i bother responding over and over. Ai has short term memory less

 

[Skara]

Lmao you’re so retarded

Just because migration compensates in the short term doesn’t mean it solves underlying problems.

The fact that the top agricultural countrie Russia, Canada, and China have less than 10% of their farmers as immigrants shows that relying on a foreign workforce is not a sustainable long term solution. Why have an influx of immigrants if they’ll just be detrimental later on. Get this through your thick fucking pea brain skull



Idk can you not fucking read? Ive said this countless of times

Addressing the broken system with proper investment in housing, healthcare, and wages. Promote job creation, reform labor markets. Immigration isn’t a fix to any of these things you retard

Have you finally gotten it?

If we are faced with a labor shortage, an aging population, and a declining GDP right now, the consequences will be worse and harder to fix. Do you wait for a new generation to grow up to fill the jobs, or do you solve the problem now? A normal person will choose the latter, and a degenerate like you will choose the former.
"muh canada rusisa chia" In these countries, agriculture is not a priority sector for attracting immigrants.

 

[Skara]

LOL

that shit actually makes so much sense

No wonder that retard thinks thinks short term solutions that will be detrimental in long term, is good.

Over for him. He has to use an AI because he can’t even articulate what he’s trying to say.

I'm not so stupid that I can actually give you full answers myself, it's much easier to piss on you with formulations from the AI because it's easier that way

oh so u are using gpt. nvm bro gg. Im not talking to an ai. its like talking to a blank wall dawg. No matter how much times I explain it ur repeating urself, i think a human is intilligent enough to not repeat himself 1000 times so its pretty obvious ur just using ai. Why would i bother responding over and over. Ai has short term memory less

so you lost

 

[FiendFiend]

I'm not so stupid that I can actually give you full answers myself, it's much easier to piss on you with formulations from the AI because it's easier that way

so you lost

i apperantly lost cuz I am repeating myself 1000 times to the ai , and im debating with an ai and not you. Fucking fantastic.

 

[FiendFiend]

I'm not so stupid that I can actually give you full answers myself, it's much easier to piss on you with formulations from the AI because it's easier that way

so you lost

The ai is so fucking retarded , a human can remember some shit i brought up 2 sentences ago, an ai fucking cant. I could tell this is ai cuz how fucking retarded and generic the anwsers are. I still debunked your faggot ai, but the ai just keeps repeating itself cuz its big tech dog shit

 

[Skara]

i apperantly lost cuz I am repeating myself 1000 times to the ai , and im debating with an ai and not you. Fucking fantastic.

AI says the same thing that I would say myself. The only difference is that I don't write the text, but AI because I'm too lazy to write
You are not debating to gpt, you are debating to me

 

[FiendFiend]

AI says the same thing that I would say myself. The only difference is that I don't write the text, but AI because I'm too lazy to write
You are not debating to gpt, you are debating to me

the amount of mental gymnastics this guy will do to cope is incredible

 

[Skara]

The ai is so fucking retarded , a human can remember some shit i brought up 2 sentences ago, an ai fucking cant. I could tell this is ai cuz how fucking retarded and generic the anwsers are. I still debunked your faggot ai, but the ai just keeps repeating itself cuz its big tech dog shit

you haven't debunked shit, you're just ignoring it while saying some naive nonsense

 

[TiktokUser]

AI says the same thing that I would say myself. The only difference is that I don't write the text, but AI because I'm too lazy to write
You are not debating to gpt, you are debating to me

No you wouldn’t

You and AI cannot understand that short term solutions will just cause an even larger increase in damage to the economy. Show me actual economic data that shows having a mass influx of immigration, without ever fixing the systemic issues will be better

Show me

It is also now transparent what the AI writes, and what you write. You don’t have the mental capability to understand such things

 

[FiendFiend]

you haven't debunked shit, you're just ignoring it while saying some naive nonsense

Mr Skara. I have responded to EVERYTHING u have brought up. You even sat there like a good fucking dog and said "ok yes i understand". You were left speechless by my exquisite writing. I am like Shakespeare compared to you of how I write shit. This conversation is too low IQ for you to understand that you need to use AI.

If I want to debate AI I will do that myself. Have a good day

 

[Skara]

No you wouldn’t

You and AI cannot understand that short term solutions will just cause an even larger increase in damage to the economy. Show me actual economic data that shows having a mass influx of immigration, without ever fucking the systemic issues will be better

"Short-term solutions will cause more damage to the economy"
empty nonsense without evidence. and even if migrants lead to long-term problems, they can still be deported at any time

Show me

It is also now transparent what the AI writes, and what you write. You don’t have the mental capability to understand such things

you have no mental capacity and that's why you blame the Jews and want to overthrow them (the bourgeoisie) because you are a commie

 

[Skara]

Mr Skara. I have responded to EVERYTHING u have brought up. You even sat there like a good fucking dog and said "ok yes i understand". You were left speechless by my exquisite writing. I am like Shakespeare compared to you of how I write shit. This conversation is too low IQ for you to understand that you need to use AI.

If I want to debate AI I will do that myself. Have a good day

you have nothing to do with it, i even used ai to write this thread

 

[TiktokUser]

Short-term solutions will cause more damage to the economy"
empty nonsense without evidence. and even if migrants lead to long-term problems, they can still be deported at any time

Does Monetary Policy Have Long-Run Effects? - San Francisco Fed

Monetary policy is often regarded as having only temporary effects on the economy, moderating the expansions and contractions that make up the business cycle. However, it is possible for monetary policy to affect an economy’s long-run trajectory. Analyzing cross-country data for a set of large...

www.frbsf.org

study shows the idea that short term solutions, can cause long term economic harm. The research shows that even though the policy may have short term benefits, such as controlling inflation. it will lead to significant reductions in potential economic output that last for years.

Now show me your pseudoscience data that “claims” short term solutions will be better for the economy? Can your AI not do that? Lmao fucking retard

All you do is switch the question onto others, when you don’t have the intelligence to throughly think about it yourself

 

[Skara]

Does Monetary Policy Have Long-Run Effects? - San Francisco Fed

Monetary policy is often regarded as having only temporary effects on the economy, moderating the expansions and contractions that make up the business cycle. However, it is possible for monetary policy to affect an economy’s long-run trajectory. Analyzing cross-country data for a set of large...

www.frbsf.org

study shows the idea that short term solutions, can cause long term economic harm. The research shows that even though the policy may have short term benefits, such as controlling inflation. it will lead to significant reductions in potential economic output that last for years.

we can only guess how it will work in the long term, we can't see the future and say for sure. In any case, if some serious problems start to appear then migrants can be deported

Now show me your pseudoscience data that “claims” short term solutions will be better for the economy? Can your AI not do that? Lmao fucking retard

this solution is better in the short term, I didn't say anything about the long term

 

[TiktokUser]

we can only guess how it will work in the long term, we can't see the future and say for sure. In any case, if some serious problems start to appear then migrants can be deported

There is no “guess.” It has already been proven. Just admit you’re fucking wrong. Can an AI not help you read a study? You clearly need it

this solution is better in the short term, I didn't say anything about the long term

Thanks for conceding

You admitted it’s not better long term, and that it will lead to even more economic devastation

You really plugged this into your AI, read it, and really thought “this will be a good response “

 

[Skara]

There is no “guess.” It has already been proven. Just admit you’re fucking wrong. Can an AI not help you read a study? You clearly need it

how the fuck is it "proven"? your study from mumbai university doesn't prove anything because mass immigration is a new phenomenon and hasn't manifested itself in the long term yet

Thanks for conceding

You admitted it’s not better long term, and that it will lead to even more economic devastation

You really plugged this into your AI, read it, and really thought “this will be a good response “

never said that it will lead to even more economic devastation. again attributing to me things i didn't say lol that's the only thing you can do

 

[TiktokUser]

how the fuck is it "proven"? your study from mumbai university doesn't prove anything because mass immigration is a new phenomenon and hasn't manifested itself in the long term yet

never said that it will lead to even more economic devastation. again attributing to me things i didn't say lol that's the only thing you can do

lol you didn’t even bother to read even the title of it before “muh it’s wrong“ use your ai you kike. Can it not do it?

If you still think you’re correct, then show me an
Academic study that shows short term solutions, that will be detrimental long term, somehow improves the economic state, and not worsens

 

[Skara]

lol you didn’t even bother to read even the title of it before “muh it’s wrong“ use your ai you kike. Can it not do it?

to debunk your absurd take I don't even need to read the title, I just use logic instead

If you still think you’re correct, then show me an
Academic study that shows short term solutions, that will be detrimental long term, somehow improves the economic state, and not worsens

I'm correct but I don't have to show you anything
Google for these studies yourself if you're so interested.