Would it be selfish to save a person from sewer-slide knowing they will be severely disabled after being saved?

[Cleetus Cornfield]

It is well known that failed sewer-slide attempts can sadly leave people with severe disabilities. Would it be selfish if you were to save a person who no longer wishes to exist and force them to live life of pain and no autonomy?

 

[Mosh12]

 

[Cleetus Cornfield]

yes or no?

 

[Mosh12]

yes or no?

no

 

[RecessedBoss]

Would the person still be depressed after this or no?
If they are still depressed,then it would be amoral
If not then it's moral

 

[RecessedBoss]

Good thread made me think

 

[Cleetus Cornfield]

Would the person still be depressed after this or no?
If they are still depressed,then it would be amoral
If not then it's moral

They would likely be more depressed as the previous thoughts are still with them and they are now unable to move.