Mass immigration is good

[JBcollector]

there are not enough workers - that means they need people. That's it. No magic. And the Nazis who shout about 'great replacement' don't even understand that it is immigrants who save their economies from degradation. Without them - less taxes, less consumption, fewer workers, higher prices. Their 'pure nation' is bankrupt.
Immigration is simply a logical response to economic and demographic demands, and not a "Jewish attacking against the white race"
>B-but muh they destroy out culture
the culture doesn't belong to you, it's not your personal thing, and therefore why are you protecting it?

depends on the country of immigration and who are immigrants are

 

[JBcollector]

if white people mass immigrated to lets say srilanka and displaced it's native population and took over the island it's would be a overall good outcome

 

[TiktokUser]

you yourself admitted that absolute GDP is growing, which means the economy is objectively increasing, and if you are interested in GDP per capita, then look at its growth taking into account time and other factors, including the level of automation and global trends

immigration closes the labor shortage, especially in countries with falling birth rates and an aging population; if everything were solved by internal measures, you would have already seen the result, but no, demand exceeds supply @TiktokUser

your idea that all the poor suffer from immigration is shattered by dozens of studies that show that the short-term effect is minimal, but in the long term it stimulates growth and innovation

It grew 4.3% in 16 years. That’s basically flat, especially compared to the 46% growth in the 16 years before. Add in the fact that productivity growth has been at its lowest in 200 years, and your “objectively increasing economy” looks a lot more like stagnation. You just don’t understand economic data to process that you’re wrong

If that influx outpaces your country’s ability to build infrastructure, housing, and offer services, you don’t get a booming economy, you get rising rents, longer hospital waits, and squeezed wages.

Link these dozens of studies then bud. All you do is say “Nuh uh “, while arguing with literal economic data . Absolute autism.
pretending unrelate unregulated mass immigration is this economic engine while ignoring its trade offs speaks of your retardation once more.

 

[Skara]

It grew 4.3% in 16 years. That’s basically flat, especially compared to the 46% growth in the 16 years before. Add in the fact that productivity growth has been at its lowest in 200 years, and your “objectively increasing economy” looks a lot more like stagnation. You just don’t understand economic data to process that you’re wrong

If that influx outpaces your country’s ability to build infrastructure, housing, and offer services, you don’t get a booming economy, you get rising rents, longer hospital waits, and squeezed wages.

Link these dozens of studies then bud. All you do is say “Nuh uh “, while arguing with literal economic data . Absolute autism.
pretending unrelate unregulated mass immigration is this economic engine while ignoring its trade offs speaks of your retardation once more.

you just ignore my argument i tagged you for and you said some bullshit that makes 0 sense
i will said it again: immigration closes the labor shortage, especially in countries with falling birth rates and an aging population; if everything were solved by internal measures, you would have already seen the result, but no, demand exceeds supply

 

[Michelangelo]

there are not enough workers - that means they need people. That's it. No magic. And the Nazis who shout about 'great replacement' don't even understand that it is immigrants who save their economies from degradation. Without them - less taxes, less consumption, fewer workers, higher prices. Their 'pure nation' is bankrupt.
Immigration is simply a logical response to economic and demographic demands, and not a "Jewish attacking against the white race"
>B-but muh they destroy out culture
the culture doesn't belong to you, it's not your personal thing, and therefore why are you protecting it?

This is definitely from someone that comes from a country with no illegal immigration or lives in a gated community

 

[TiktokUser]

you just ignore my argument i tagged you for and you said some bullshit that makes 0 sense
i will said it again: immigration closes the labor shortage, especially in countries with falling birth rates and an aging population; if everything were solved by internal measures, you would have already seen the result, but no, demand exceeds supply

And did that close the labour shortage? Fuck no. It didn’t solve the core issue, it delays it while introducing new ones. Importing workers to plug gaps caused by low birth rates without addressing why people aren’t having kids or why locals are leaving key sectors is like taping over a leaking pipe

If demand exceeds supply, maybe ask why, why aren’t domestic workers filling roles? Is it because wages are low, housing is unaffordable, childcare costs are insane, and public services are overburdened? Mass immigration doesn’t solve those, it makes them worse and data already shows this which you still deny.




You’re acting like immigration is a silver bullet. It’s a tool — and when you use the wrong tool for the wrong problem, you just end up masking structural decay with short-term band-aids. And that’s exactly what’s been happening.

 

[Michelangelo]

i live outside of any country though

We all know you dont. but right, Israel isnt a country afterall

 

[Skara]

And did that close the labour shortage? Fuck no. It didn’t solve the core issue, it delays it while introducing new ones. Importing workers to plug gaps caused by low birth rates without addressing why people aren’t having kids or why locals are leaving key sectors is like taping over a leaking pipe

If demand exceeds supply, maybe ask why, why aren’t domestic workers filling roles? Is it because wages are low, housing is unaffordable, childcare costs are insane, and public services are overburdened? Mass immigration doesn’t solve those, it makes them worse and data already shows this which you still deny.




You’re acting like immigration is a silver bullet. It’s a tool — and when you use the wrong tool for the wrong problem, you just end up masking structural decay with short-term band-aids. And that’s exactly what’s been happening.

You repeat the theses of anti-immigration populists, but ignore reality because you are an idiot.
Without migrants, Germany/Japan/Canada would have already had a collapse of medicine and construction. Where is your 'magic plan' to replace 2 million workers in the EU annually?

Yes, infrastructure should grow along with the population - but this is a problem for governments, not migrants. In Canada they decide this, in the UK - no, hence the different results.

You mix legal labor migration and uncontrolled flows. The first gives +4% to GDP per capita (OECD), the second creates problems.
References to 'stagnation' are ridiculous: if it weren't for migrants, you wouldn't have 'low growth', you'd have a full-blown recession.

You ignore that without immigration, the labor shortage would be catastrophic (for example, in the EU by 2050 there will be 1 worker for 1 pensioner)
You assume that wages will increase if migration is banned, but in reality, businesses can simply move production abroad (like in the UK after Brexit).
You compare different eras: economic growth in the 1970s-2000s was associated with the technological boom, and not just with demographics.
This is my last reply to you, I will not continue to argue with your populist rhetoric

 

[Skara]

We all know you dont. but right, Israel isnt a country afterall

geographically i live on occupied territory by this pest called "russian federation" it's urals. I don't recognize this pest so therefore i don't live in it

 

[Michelangelo]

geographically i live on occupied territory by this pest called "russian federation" it's urals. I don't recognize this pest so therefore i don't live in it

Sounds like the russians just wanted to immigrate, doesnt sound like a bad thing.
See you do live in a country afterall

 

[TiktokUser]

You repeat the theses of anti-immigration populists, but ignore reality because you are an idiot.
Without migrants, Germany/Japan/Canada would have already had a collapse of medicine and construction. Where is your 'magic plan' to replace 2 million workers in the EU annually?

Yes, infrastructure should grow along with the population - but this is a problem for governments, not migrants. In Canada they decide this, in the UK - no, hence the different results.

You mix legal labor migration and uncontrolled flows. The first gives +4% to GDP per capita (OECD), the second creates problems.
References to 'stagnation' are ridiculous: if it weren't for migrants, you wouldn't have 'low growth', you'd have a full-blown recession.

You ignore that without immigration, the labor shortage would be catastrophic (for example, in the EU by 2050 there will be 1 worker for 1 pensioner)
You assume that wages will increase if migration is banned, but in reality, businesses can simply move production abroad (like in the UK after Brexit).
You compare different eras: economic growth in the 1970s-2000s was associated with the technological boom, and not just with demographics.
This is my last reply to you, I will not continue to argue with your populist rhetoric

pretending that importing millions of workers annually is some kind of flawless solution, not a desperate patch for a broken system
you’re so mentally ill

You’re admitting the system can’t sustain itself without immigration, which isn’t a win, it’s a red flag that decades of policy have built zero internal resilience. Maybe address why fertility rates are collapsing, why young people can’t afford kids or homes, and why wages have flatlined rather than just blaming it all on demographics and calling it a day.

if mass migration overwhelms that infrastructure and housing supply before governments act (which they rarely do), who suffers? Migrants and natives alike. Saying “it’s the government’s fault” doesn’t change the real world outcomes of strained schools, hospitals, and transit.

a +4% to GDP per capita from legal labor migration doesn’t negate the unequal distribution of that benefit. Most of that growth goes to capital owners and high skill sectors, while the working class is left competing in saturated low-wage markets. That’s not prosperity, that’s managed decline dressed up as progress.

strategic immigration policy, domestic investment, and actual economic reform would wage raises.

You have brutally lost this argument. Literally the data is on my side and you’re still arguing like the clown you are

 

[Skara]

Sounds like the russians just wanted to immigrate, doesnt sound like a bad thing.
See you do live in a country afterall

no shit i'm not a russian. i don't want to immigrate either, but if this pest will leave me alone i will stop hating it.
i don't live in russia.

 

[Michelangelo]

no shit i'm not a russian. i don't want to immigrate either, but if this pest will leave me alone i will stop hating it.
i don't live in russia.

Never said you were russian tho?
You said it yourself, you live in occupied territory under russian federation, which means you live in Russia (an actual country).
As ive said they have simply immigrated into your home, why do you hate russians tho? You sound extremely xenophobic

 

[Michelangelo]

How ironic that this thread was typed by someone with no country, wether that would be Israel or the place he now lives in, which he does not even recognize as a country

 

[666PSL]

I dont really care. Just have free movement so you can go where you please ngl. I dont buy the economic growth arguments though since i dont care about gdp

When did you come back

 

[Skara]

pretending that importing millions of workers annually is some kind of flawless solution, not a desperate patch for a broken system
you’re so mentally ill

You’re admitting the system can’t sustain itself without immigration, which isn’t a win, it’s a red flag that decades of policy have built zero internal resilience. Maybe address why fertility rates are collapsing, why young people can’t afford kids or homes, and why wages have flatlined rather than just blaming it all on demographics and calling it a day.

if mass migration overwhelms that infrastructure and housing supply before governments act (which they rarely do), who suffers? Migrants and natives alike. Saying “it’s the government’s fault” doesn’t change the real world outcomes of strained schools, hospitals, and transit.

a +4% to GDP per capita from legal labor migration doesn’t negate the unequal distribution of that benefit. Most of that growth goes to capital owners and high skill sectors, while the working class is left competing in saturated low-wage markets. That’s not prosperity, that’s managed decline dressed up as progress.

strategic immigration policy, domestic investment, and actual economic reform would wage raises.

You have brutally lost this argument. Literally the data is on my side and you’re still arguing like the clown you are

you keep saying the same shit and you don't debunk what I said, you just ignore it, the only thing that changes is the wording. There is no point in wasting more time on you, you have lost, good bye

Never said you were russian tho?
You said it yourself, you live in occupied territory under russian federation, which means you live in Russia (an actual country).
As ive said they have simply immigrated into your home, why do you hate russians tho? You sound extremely xenophobic

i don't hate russians, i just don't give a fuck about them, i even used to think that i'm a russian myself whole my life but decided to give it up, i'm not it anymore, just proves that i'm not xenophobic

>Never said you were russian tho?
but i just thought you called me russian when you said that "Sounds like the russians just wanted to immigrate, doesnt sound like a bad thing."
the fact that I was born in a certain territory does not mean that I can be attributed to any state, I am not in Russia, that's all

 

[Deleted member 124785]

Also you making mistake by thinking nazis care if their fully european state is poor. Prosperity isnt in picture. Making the economy argument to them wont work, you need to attack them from a different angle, that being sexual insecurity. scared of getting cucked

*Muh Dick*

 

[Deleted member 124785]

LOL TWO RETARDED NIGGER DEBATING WHEATHER THEY WILL ALLOW SHITSKIN AND MUHAMMAD TO DESTROY THEIR COUNTRY AND RAPE THEIR FEMALE OR NOT. YOU NIGGER SO RETARDED. I DON'T HATE IMMIGRANT TBH BECAUSE MOST LEGAL ONE ARE RIGHTFULLY HERE BUT I DON'T SUPPORT THE FUCKING ILLEGAL LOWIQ ONE AND A FUCKING REFUGEES. BTW NIGGA WHEN WILL USA LOWER THE VISA-SPONSOR RATE SO I CAN WORK IN THE US AS A FUCKING CONSTRUCTION WORKER AND FINALLY GET OUT OF THIS THIRD WORLD SHITHOLE???

 

[TiktokUser]

you keep saying the same shit and you don't debunk what I said, you just ignore it, the only thing that changes is the wording. There is no point in wasting more time on you, you have lost, good bye

“Muh governments mismanage, immigration is a quick fix “

hundreds of data, and countless of countries who have tried this have all led to a worse economic state. You’re such a mentally ill kike femboy that is unable process the simplest things.

Leave the argument once again little kike boy, because you can’t actually make a solid rebuttal to any of my fucking points.

This is how retarded you are. You should be castrated and stripped of your rights you dumb faggot. You’re wrong about everything, and still blindly argue even when given economic data because your little brain can’t process it

 

[Skara]

LOL TWO RETARDED NIGGER DEBATING WHEATHER THEY WILL ALLOW SHITSKIN AND MUHAMMAD TO DESTROY THEIR COUNTRY AND RAPE THEIR FEMALE OR NOT. YOU NIGGER SO RETARDED. I DON'T HATE IMMIGRANT TBH BECAUSE MOST LEGAL ONE ARE RIGHTFULLY HERE BUT I DON'T SUPPORT THE FUCKING ILLEGAL LOWIQ ONE AND A FUCKING REFUGEES. BTW NIGGA WHEN WILL USA LOWER THE VISA-SPONSOR RATE SO I CAN WORK IN THE US AS A FUCKING CONSTRUCTION WORKER AND FINALLY GET OUT OF THIS THIRD WORLD SHITHOLE???

no shit the country doesn't belong to me, it's not my personal own but it imposes it's will, system, language, symbols. Therefore i hate it and will be fine if immigrants destroy it

 

[DieVoGel6949]

there are not enough workers - that means they need people. That's it. No magic. And the Nazis who shout about 'great replacement' don't even understand that it is immigrants who save their economies from degradation. Without them - less taxes, less consumption, fewer workers, higher prices. Their 'pure nation' is bankrupt.
Immigration is simply a logical response to economic and demographic demands, and not a "Jewish attacking against the white race"
>B-but muh they destroy out culture
the culture doesn't belong to you, it's not your personal thing, and therefore why are you protecting it?

White people should've made more kids tbh and this would've never happend

 

[Deleted member 124785]

White people should've made more kids tbh and this would've never happend

THEY ARE BUSY CUTTING THEIR DICK OFF AND ON THAT FEMBOY TRANNY JEWISH BULLSHIT NIGGA. ITSOVER FOR THEM. I WANT WHITE TO SURVIVE AND KEEP STRIVING CUZ THEY MAKE THE BEST FEMBOY!!

 

[Skara]

“Muh governments mismanage, immigration is a quick fix “

hundreds of data, and countless of countries who have tried this have all led to a worse economic state. You’re such a mentally ill kike femboy that is unable process the simplest things.

Leave the argument once again little kike boy, because you can’t actually make a solid rebuttal to any of my fucking points.

This is how retarded you are. You should be castrated and stripped of your rights you dumb faggot. You’re wrong about everything, and still blindly argue even when given economic data because your little brain can’t process it

you haven't debunked shit, keep saying the same bullshit

 

[Michelangelo]

>Never said you were russian tho?
but i just thought you called me russian when you said that "Sounds like the russians just wanted to immigrate, doesnt sound like a bad thing."
the fact that I was born in a certain territory does not mean that I can be attributed to any state, I am not in Russia, that's all

Idgf about your nationality, its clear that you live in a country and u enjoy all the infrastructures and services the gov might open to the public, so its not like you dont live in no country. Yes, you do actually live in russia from what you are describing you indeed probably also pay taxes unless you are broke af, live w your parents or dont own anything, you can cope however you want about this it wont change, you also probably have russian citizenship if you were born in russian territory anyway, if thats a bad or good thing for you i honestly dont care, if anything you are the parasite that migrated to russia, as urals have been russian land for centuries

 

[Michelangelo]

no shit the country doesn't belong to me, it's not my personal own but it imposes it's will, system, language, symbols. Therefore i hate it and will be fine if immigrants destroy it

You dont belong to any country, clearly

 

[Imretarded?]

When did you come back

like a day ago

*Muh Dick*

literally. Racists are scared of competition. Really says a lot that they're scared a peanut skulled somali mogs them

 

[TiktokUser]

you haven't debunked shit, keep saying the same bullshit

“muh you haven’t debunked anything “

>You claim that immigration is the sole solution to labor shortages, but you fail to acknowledge the systemic issues in housing, wages, and worker quality of life that mass immigration only temporarily masks, rather than solving.

> You argue that without immigration, there would be a recession, but you ignore how immigration itself doesn’t always benefit the working class, in fact, many immigrants take lower wage jobs that don’t translate into long term growth for the majority of the population. As showed with the GDP per capita tanking

> You point to the OECD stat of +4% GDP per capita growth, but fail to address that this growth is often unequally distributed, it mostly benefits high skill sectors and capital owners, leaving the working class to struggle with stagnating wages.

>You say government mismanagement is the real issue, but consistently avoid discussing the consequences of relying on immigration to fill gaps without addressing the root causes, such as declining birth rates or affordability of living.

> You accuse me of repeating the same points without debunking your arguments, but the truth is you continuously dodge addressing the core contradictions and prefer to make sweeping statements without proper counterpoints.

only a mentally ill kike can be showed economic data and still deny it

 

[Skara]

Idgf about your nationality, its clear that you live in a country and u enjoy all the infrastructures and services the gov might open to the public, so its not like you dont live in no country. Yes, you do actually live in russia from what you are describing you indeed probably also pay taxes unless you are broke af, live w your parents or dont own anything, you can cope however you want about this it wont change, you also probably have russian citizenship if you were born in russian territory anyway, if thats a bad or good thing for you i honestly dont care, if anything you are the parasite that migrated to russia, as urals have been russian land for centuries

a standard set of logical fallacies, imperial fantasies and dogmatic logic.
I didn't choose to use the infrastructure - it's monopolized. There are simply no alternatives. If you don't want to pay taxes - go to jail. If you don't want to have a passport - go without medicine, an account, a phone, a SIM card, or the Internet. This is not a choice - it's violence. I don't recognize authority over myself simply because I was born in a certain territory.

>You pay taxes - that means you are part of the country
No. It's like paying tribute to a racketeer so he doesn't break your legs. It's not support, it's extortion.

>citizen by birth
No, I didn't sign a contract for this, they just imposed on me that I am a citizen just because I was born here lol, it sounds absurd

>You are a migrant because the Urals are Russian land
The Urals are not Russian, they were captured by Russians but they are not Russian. The land does not belong to the flag.

 

[Michelangelo]

>You are a migrant because the Urals are Russian land
The Urals are not Russian, they were captured by Russians but they are not Russian. The land does not belong to the flag

MUH LAND MUH LAND holy shit stop crying, you can repeat yourself how borders are imaginary lines it wont change anything, you are russian by definition of those same imaginary lines which still impact your life in a realistic and physical way.

a standard set of logical fallacies, imperial fantasies and dogmatic logic.
I didn't choose to use the infrastructure - it's monopolized. There are simply no alternatives. If you don't want to pay taxes - go to jail. If you don't want to have a passport - go without medicine, an account, a phone, a SIM card, or the Internet. This is not a choice - it's violence. I don't recognize authority over myself simply because I was born in a certain territory

Oh poor thing, you were born in a civilized society with services and infrastructures that were there to provide you with medicines, passports, internet connection and a fucking SIM card? Thats fucking tiranny bro how are you living like this?

 

[Michelangelo]

>You pay taxes - that means you are part of the country
No. It's like paying tribute to a racketeer so he doesn't break your legs. It's not support, it's exextortion.

Almost as if people needs to pay money for having certain services that are vital for society to function, how weird

 

[Skara]

“muh you haven’t debunked anything “
View attachment 3627043

>You claim that immigration is the sole solution to labor shortages, but you fail to acknowledge the systemic issues in housing, wages, and worker quality of life that mass immigration only temporarily masks, rather than solving.

> You argue that without immigration, there would be a recession, but you ignore how immigration itself doesn’t always benefit the working class, in fact, many immigrants take lower wage jobs that don’t translate into long term growth for the majority of the population. As showed with the GDP per capita tanking

> You point to the OECD stat of +4% GDP per capita growth, but fail to address that this growth is often unequally distributed, it mostly benefits high skill sectors and capital owners, leaving the working class to struggle with stagnating wages.

>You say government mismanagement is the real issue, but consistently avoid discussing the consequences of relying on immigration to fill gaps without addressing the root causes, such as declining birth rates or affordability of living.

> You accuse me of repeating the same points without debunking your arguments, but the truth is you continuously dodge addressing the core contradictions and prefer to make sweeping statements without proper counterpoints.

only a mentally ill kike can be showed economic data and still deny it

you crying about housing and wages like immigrants control zoning laws, set minimum wage and offshore capital. retarded take. they don’t mask shit, they keep the broken machine running while your precious government sucks off landlords and investors. your brain too small to understand the cause, so you attack the effect.

you talk GDP per capita like it’s your religion but don’t even know what affects it. immigrants don’t tank shit, hoarded capital and wage theft does. you just too brain-dead to look at who’s actually taking the pie. it's your bosses, not some afghan construction worker. cope harder.

You point to the OECD stat of +4% GDP per capita growth, but fail to address that this growth is often unequally distributed, it mostly benefits high skill sectors and capital owners, leaving the working class to struggle with stagnating wages.

exactly you fucking autist, you just made my point. there IS growth, it's just stolen by the same people you’re defending. you crying for the working class while shilling for the system that rapes it. absolute faggot clown logic.

government mismanagement is the real issue, but consistently avoid discussing the consequences of relying on immigration to fill gaps without addressing the root causes, such as declining birth rates or affordability of living.

holy shit how fucking dumb are you. the causes are unaffordable life and dead wages — which exist because of the government and economic structure — not because muh immigrants. you see the fire but blame the smoke. textbook NPC.


you literally just recycle the same “but immigrants bad” shit on loop like a broken tranny sexbot. you don’t have arguments, you just have fear and rage and too many hours on thread. your brain is factory-reset every morning.

 

[Michelangelo]

“muh you haven’t debunked anything “
View attachment 3627043

>You claim that immigration is the sole solution to labor shortages, but you fail to acknowledge the systemic issues in housing, wages, and worker quality of life that mass immigration only temporarily masks, rather than solving.

> You argue that without immigration, there would be a recession, but you ignore how immigration itself doesn’t always benefit the working class, in fact, many immigrants take lower wage jobs that don’t translate into long term growth for the majority of the population. As showed with the GDP per capita tanking

> You point to the OECD stat of +4% GDP per capita growth, but fail to address that this growth is often unequally distributed, it mostly benefits high skill sectors and capital owners, leaving the working class to struggle with stagnating wages.

>You say government mismanagement is the real issue, but consistently avoid discussing the consequences of relying on immigration to fill gaps without addressing the root causes, such as declining birth rates or affordability of living.

> You accuse me of repeating the same points without debunking your arguments, but the truth is you continuously dodge addressing the core contradictions and prefer to make sweeping statements without proper counterpoints.

only a mentally ill kike can be showed economic data and still deny it

You are quite literally discussing with someone that doesnt know what taxes are for, its all useless

 

[Skara]

MUH LAND MUH LAND holy shit stop crying, you can repeat yourself how borders are imaginary lines it wont change anything, you are russian by definition of those same imaginary lines which still impact your life in a realistic and physical way.

I do not recognize these lines and am not obliged to because I did not sign any agreement, therefore this "Russian influence" is simply violence against me

Oh poor thing, you were born in a civilized society with services and infrastructures that were there to provide you with medicines, passports, internet connection and a fucking SIM card? Thats fucking tiranny bro how are you living like this?

I didn't sign any agreement that I can use something, but at the same time I'm obligated to do something in return. I use medicine, the Internet, etc., but I didn't sign anything to be obligated to the state to do something in return.

 

[Michelangelo]

>You are a migrant because the Urals are Russian land
The Urals are not Russian, they were captured by Russians but they are not Russian. The land does not belong to the flag.

Erm-ermmm the Russian have conquered this land centuries ago but I tell you, i tell you this isnt actually their land bro, i live under their tiranny but the land isnt theirs bro i swear.
It was actually promised to me 2000 years ago

 

[Skara]

I know what taxes are for, but it's still a theft of my personal money because I never gave any permission for it to be taken away.

You are quite literally discussing with someone that doesnt know what taxes are for, its all useless

i destroyed him, read it:

you crying about housing and wages like immigrants control zoning laws, set minimum wage and offshore capital. retarded take. they don’t mask shit, they keep the broken machine running while your precious government sucks off landlords and investors. your brain too small to understand the cause, so you attack the effect.

you talk GDP per capita like it’s your religion but don’t even know what affects it. immigrants don’t tank shit, hoarded capital and wage theft does. you just too brain-dead to look at who’s actually taking the pie. it's your bosses, not some afghan construction worker. cope harder.

exactly you fucking autist, you just made my point. there IS growth, it's just stolen by the same people you’re defending. you crying for the working class while shilling for the system that rapes it. absolute faggot clown logic.

holy shit how fucking dumb are you. the causes are unaffordable life and dead wages — which exist because of the government and economic structure — not because muh immigrants. you see the fire but blame the smoke. textbook NPC.


you literally just recycle the same “but immigrants bad” shit on loop like a broken tranny sexbot. you don’t have arguments, you just have fear and rage and too many hours on thread. your brain is factory-reset every morning.

 

[Skara]

View attachment 3627106
Erm-ermmm the Russian have conquered this land centuries ago but I tell you, i tell you this isnt actually their land bro, i live under their tiranny but the land isnt theirs bro i swear.
It was actually promised to me 2000 years ago

These are people with guns who have occupied the land and now think that they can impose their will on me just because I was born here. by your logic, every rape is a marriage and every robbery is a business transaction

 

[Skara]

You are quite literally discussing with someone that doesnt know what taxes are for, its all useless

you saying “they conquered it” like it justifies anything. ok, and? that means nothing to me. I didn’t conquer shit, I didn’t sign shit, and I sure as fuck don’t owe shit to the parasites who built their “nation” on violence and now cry that I don’t kiss their boots for it.

 

[Michelangelo]

I do not recognize these lines and am not obliged to because I did not sign any agreement, therefore this "Russian influence" is simply violence against me

I didn't sign any agreement that I can use something, but at the same time I'm obligated to do something in return. I use medicine, the Internet, etc., but I didn't sign anything to be obligated to the state to do something in return.

Atp just go live to whatever is jewish wakanda, if you think society is perpetuating such violence on you just because you are born and feel like such a victim.
You do pay money and for the Internet tho, but yeah keep coping

 

[Skara]

Atp just go live to whatever is jewish wakanda, if you think society is perpetuating such violence on you just because you are born and feel like such a victim.
You do pay money and for the Internet tho, but yeah keep coping

I pay money for the Internet because I personally signed up for it. For paying taxes - no, that means it's just stealing

 

[Michelangelo]

These are people with guns who have occupied the land and now think that they can impose their will on me just because I was born here. by your logic, every rape is a marriage and every robbery is a business transaction

Nah you are just that subhuman and mislead any kind of human logic, which is why im giving up on you

 

[Michelangelo]

i destroyed him, read it:

 

[Skara]

Nah you are just that subhuman and mislead any kind of human logic, which is why im giving up on you

"mislead any kind of human logic"
I didn't contradict myself anywhere

 

[Michelangelo]

"mislead any kind of human logic"
I didn't contradict myself anywhere

This is exactly what I was talking about

 

[TiktokUser]

you crying about housing and wages like immigrants control zoning laws, set minimum wage and offshore capital. retarded take. they don’t mask shit, they keep the broken machine running while your precious government sucks off landlords and investors. your brain too small to understand the cause, so you attack the effect.

you talk GDP per capita like it’s your religion but don’t even know what affects it. immigrants don’t tank shit, hoarded capital and wage theft does. you just too brain-dead to look at who’s actually taking the pie. it's your bosses, not some afghan construction worker. cope harder.

exactly you fucking autist, you just made my point. there IS growth, it's just stolen by the same people you’re defending. you crying for the working class while shilling for the system that rapes it. absolute faggot clown logic.

holy shit how fucking dumb are you. the causes are unaffordable life and dead wages — which exist because of the government and economic structure — not because muh immigrants. you see the fire but blame the smoke. textbook NPC.


you literally just recycle the same “but immigrants bad” shit on loop like a broken tranny sexbot. you don’t have arguments, you just have fear and rage and too many hours on thread. your brain is factory-reset every morning.

“Immigrants don’t control zoning laws, minimum wage, or offshore capital ”


When did I say they do. Just logical fallacies over logical fallacies. You’re so retarded that you have to use strawmans because you’re too retarded to understand basic economic data. Nothing you said in this response debunked a single thing. Once again I must repeat myself cause you’re a brain dead weirdo femboy loser. Go overdose on your depression medication you faggot

mass immigration can worsen housing shortages and wage stagnation, both of which are directly influenced by immigration driven demand. You can’t pretend immigrants don’t play a role in the supply demand imbalance when you flood the labor market with low wage workers. Immigration doesn’t fix the system, it maintains it, and the real beneficiaries are often corporations and investors, not the working class.


“Immigrants keep the broken machine running “

Immigration doesn’t solve the structural issues of inequality, it just keeps the system alive while wealth continues to be hoarded.


highlighting that GDP growth without addressing income inequality or quality of life is meaningless. GDP per capita has plummeted yet you still argue cause you’re too retarded to read about the statistics even when given them.


immigration doesn’t solve these problems
, it often aggravates them by flooding the labor market and reducing bargaining power for low-
income workers. Acting like immigration is some magic fix for a fundamentally broken system. It’s part of the problem, not the solution.

Delete your account and overdose on your medication you werido fag. No surprise that a mentally ill femboy can’t understand per capita

 

[TiktokUser]

You are quite literally discussing with someone that doesnt know what taxes are for, its all useless

Makes sense honestly. This kike doesn’t even understand what “per capita” means


and because the GDP went up due to the influx of immigration, he thinks that automatically means the economy is better, when it’s not. The increase in GDP isn’t translating to better living standards for the average person. If he simply took a look at GDP per capita, he’d see that it’s has not even grown in the past 16 years


he only looks at raw GDP numbers, cause he’s too retarded to understand middle school data.

 

[greycelzoomer]

It should be made si immigrants are not allowed to have kids

 

[Skara]

“Immigrants don’t control zoning laws, minimum wage, or offshore capital ”


When did I say they do. Just logical fallacies over logical fallacies. You’re so retarded that you have to use strawmans because you’re too retarded to understand basic economic data. Nothing you said in this response debunked a single thing. Once again I must repeat myself cause you’re a brain dead weirdo femboy loser. Go overdose on your depression medication you faggot

mass immigration can worsen housing shortages and wage stagnation, both of which are directly influenced by immigration driven demand. You can’t pretend immigrants don’t play a role in the supply demand imbalance when you flood the labor market with low wage workers. Immigration doesn’t fix the system, it maintains it, and the real beneficiaries are often corporations and investors, not the working class.


“Immigrants keep the broken machine running “

Immigration doesn’t solve the structural issues of inequality, it just keeps the system alive while wealth continues to be hoarded.


highlighting that GDP growth without addressing income inequality or quality of life is meaningless. GDP per capita has plummeted yet you still argue cause you’re too retarded to read about the statistics even when given them.


immigration doesn’t solve these problems
, it often aggravates them by flooding the labor market and reducing bargaining power for low-
income workers. Acting like immigration is some magic fix for a fundamentally broken system. It’s part of the problem, not the solution.

Delete your account and overdose on your medication you werido fag. No surprise that a mentally ill femboy can’t understand per capita

LMAO you really typed 3 paragraphs just to say absolutely fucking nothing but the same NPC-tier whining with more slurs. imagine coping this hard cause you got intellectually slapped by someone you called a “femboy”. JFL.

When did I say they do. Just logical fallacies over logical fallacies.

you literally whined about housing and wage stagnation, and I pointed out those are results of state and capital policy, not the brown dude cleaning toilets. that’s not a strawman — that’s just your brain failing to keep up. not my fault you talk like a Fox News algorithm glitching out.

mass immigration can worsen housing shortages and wage stagnation...

yeah, and your mom’s weight worsens tectonic pressure, doesn’t mean she’s the root cause of earthquakes.
demand rises, sure — but so does labor supply, tax base, consumption, etc. the issue is capital hoarding, not Juan from Guatemala trying to pay rent. but you too busy jerking off to GDP per capita graphs to understand that supply-demand is manipulated from the top, not bottom.

GDP per capita has plummeted

no it fucking hasn’t, and if it did — it’s cause the rich hoarded the gains, not because Muh Ahmed took a job you’d never work.
you parrot "per capita" like it’s your god but cry when someone reminds you who’s hoarding the "capita". cope harder.

immigration doesn’t solve the structural issues...

nobody said it does, you illiterate donut. it’s not a fix, it’s a survival mechanism. the system is broken cause you refuse to blame capital and instead cry about people fleeing wars and poverty caused by the same elites you defend.
that’s not a take — that’s mental illness.
go kys nigger.

 

[Skara]

Makes sense honestly. This kike doesn’t even understand what “per capita” means


and because the GDP went up due to the influx of immigration, he thinks that automatically means the economy is better, when it’s not. The increase in GDP isn’t translating to better living standards for the average person. If he simply took a look at GDP per capita, he’d see that it’s has not even grown in the past 16 years


he only looks at raw GDP numbers, cause he’s too retarded to understand middle school data.

in absolute terms, GDP has grown. but per capita, no, but without immigrants, it would have fallen very sharply in 16 years, how stupid are you if you don't understand. How many times do I have to explain to you that low birth rates and aging population would have turned the country's economy into shit in 16 years if they hadn't started letting in migrants @Michelangelo JFL if you believe him retard

 

[TiktokUser]

LMAO you really typed 3 paragraphs just to say absolutely fucking nothing but the same NPC-tier whining with more slurs. imagine coping this hard cause you got intellectually slapped by someone you called a “femboy”. JFL.




you literally whined about housing and wage stagnation, and I pointed out those are results of state and capital policy, not the brown dude cleaning toilets. that’s not a strawman — that’s just your brain failing to keep up. not my fault you talk like a Fox News algorithm glitching out.




yeah, and your mom’s weight worsens tectonic pressure, doesn’t mean she’s the root cause of earthquakes.
demand rises, sure — but so does labor supply, tax base, consumption, etc. the issue is capital hoarding, not Juan from Guatemala trying to pay rent. but you too busy jerking off to GDP per capita graphs to understand that supply-demand is manipulated from the top, not bottom.




no it fucking hasn’t, and if it did — it’s cause the rich hoarded the gains, not because Muh Ahmed took a job you’d never work.
you parrot "per capita" like it’s your god but cry when someone reminds you who’s hoarding the "capita". cope harder.




nobody said it does, you illiterate donut. it’s not a fix, it’s a survival mechanism. the system is broken cause you refuse to blame capital and instead cry about people fleeing wars and poverty caused by the same elites you defend.
that’s not a take — that’s mental illness.
go kys nigger.

housing and wage stagnation aren’t just the result of state and capital policy, but immigration impacts the labor market, which affects wages and demand. You can’t just act like more people flooding the job market doesn’t have an impact on wages and housing. If you keep adding demand for housing and labor without corresponding increases in supply, it inevitably pushes prices up and wages down.

more demand, but limited supply, results in price increases. When you artificially boost labor supply through immigration, it suppresses wage growth for lower income workers. Basic economics is now a “Fox News talking point,” this is actually how retarded you are. Overdose already you retarded kike fag

The Scale of Economic Inequality in the UK - Equality Trust

The UK has very high inequality of income compared to other developed countries. The UK's wealth inequality is much more severe than income inequality.

equalitytrust.org.uk

Household disposable income and inequality in the UK - Office for National Statistics

How taxes and benefits redistribute income between various groups of households in the UK.

www.ons.gov.uk

demand rises, and so does strain on public services and infrastructure. The UK, has seen huge increases in immigration, but infrastructure (housing, schools, healthcare) hasn’t kept pace. mass Immigration doesn’t automatically result in better living conditions for everyone. Your idealistic narrative about “consumption” and “tax base” overlooks the massive inequality in how those benefits are distributed.

GDP growth we see isn’t translating into better living standards for most people. You can throw all the “capital hoarding” rhetoric around, but the wealthy have been hoarding gains since the 80s, way before mass immigration became a thing. Mass immigration doesn’t automatically solve issues, it simply compounds it. You can’t scream “capitalism is bad” and ignore that immigration alone doesn’t fix that system, it just contributes to a larger population that’s equally screwed by the same policies that benefit the Jews . Such a low iq commie

https://repository.gatech.edu/bitstreams/318ef883-8adb-4fab-9ed0-e54d5db75fd1/download?utm_source

immigration policies themselves aren’t neutral they’re shaped by capital interests. Why do you think the wealthy benefit from cheap labor that drives down wages? Immigration is often used as a tool to reduce labor costs. Which worsens the issue.

https://www.hks.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/centers/mrcbg/files/198_AWP_final.pdf?utm_source

 

[TiktokUser]

in absolute terms, GDP has grown. but per capita, no, but without immigrants, it would have fallen very sharply in 16 years, how stupid are you if you don't understand. How many times do I have to explain to you that low birth rates and aging population would have turned the country's economy into shit in 16 years if they hadn't started letting in migrants @Michelangelo JFL if you believe him retard

Another retarded paragraph by this kike
The per capita GDP is still stagnating because those gains are disproportionately concentrated at the top of the income ladder. The rise in immigration does contribute to the overall GDP, BUT that’s a result of more people rather than any actual improvement in productivity. Having repeat myself cause you’re this retarded

How the Fed Controls the Money Supply

The Federal Reserve engages in open market operations when it buys or sells securities, such as Treasury notes, from its member banks.

www.thebalancemoney.com

the solution isn’t to import labor retard. It to address the underlying issues like capital hoarding, wage suppression, and economic inequality all caused by the Jews. Low birth rates and aging populations are real problems, but they don’t require unrestricted immigration to fix. Governments could raise wages, increase automation, and implement policies that incentivize higher birth rates

https://www.oecd.org/en/about/directorates/directorate-for-employment-labour-and-social-affairs.html

You have brutally lost

You are so retarded and can’t accept defeat that you’re arguing with economic data

Hang yourself already. Your cum stained room will never be checked